Dude, sorry if I sound harsh, but youre a rank three now. Your boxes are not really up to standard compared to others of your rank. Your editing is really good for your rank, but your boxart needs help.
For starters, Never use just a plain gradient as a background. Secondly, the characters on the front are floating and just randomly spaced, as well as the wrong size in comparison to each other. The front is just generally not great. The back is slightly better but the yoshis are floating and that background is bad. The font is bland and hard to read.
#1, According to the post times, you commented on Koopa's box on the same day..... Try spending more time on your boxes. Like TMRD said, you have good editing skills, but your boxes aren't up to par with other Rank 3 boxes......
#5, Dude that's rough, you say stuff like that you'll get yourself banned because it's not nice at all.
And LaserSonic, i suggest you take a different perspective on this box, get a different background like TMRD said, I saw you post this in the WiPs and you didnt get much help with it, i love the Yoshi render on you username logo and I have to say the back is better than the front. The main problem seems to be that the pictures of the characters are all from different games so it makes the look too different graphic wise, try and find some that look similar, or try to render them, because you seem to do a good job of that :)
You need any more help on any boxes let me know because ive started taking a different perspective and mine look a lot better now.
#6-#8, I'm rude? You guys have no idea how many times I've been told that OK. It's just not a good box. Spend more time. OK thats all I'm saying. And be more creative, take a daring plunge, which may get you better. And the only reason I'm a rank 1 is because I only have like 6 boxes, your a rank 3 because of all your boxes.
#10, Yeah you're rude, your telling him to quite making boxarts, without even trying to help him out on improve. You're generally not a very nice person to people who are putting a lot of effort into their boxes if their boxes aren't very good.
The update is better, especially the back, how about finding a background for the front instead of just something on the bottom where they're standing. I say get rid of the solid color on the background of the front, i think this could become a good box.
#10, Those kind of comments such as, "Just get a new program or quit. Seriously" can be taken as breaking the "Constructive criticism" rule and you will receive a ban. I'm not sure who told you the same thing but if they did they were also in the wrong. Saying those comments do not help others improve and it is taken very seriously by the administrator and the moderators. If you have a problem with someone making rude comments toward yourself please take it up with one of the moderators in PMs.
#16, It was spypilot. I know my box wasn't very good but here it is so you can see the comment:http://vgboxart.com/view/33584/da.banana.bunch/?replies=3
#21, Rank has nothing to do with how you can treat a fellow user. This is the exact reason why I am a advocate of removing the entire rank system because it encourages elitist attitudes. The fact is every member, no matter the rank, needs to be respectful of every other member. Otherwise, how will we improve as a site?
#2, the ranks do say nothing about the skill of the artist here.
about the box: your big signature and the credits distract from your work. make it smaller and put it more in the background 'cause the page is about the box, not the credits and signatures. (this doesn't mean you should not post it on your stuff, just not like you do here)
#5, and youre the one to say that?
lol, i just about died laughing.
also, i didnt go out harsh, i said to just stop posting them, no one said anything about stopping to make em. sorry i just have problems with users (besides shadowdialga) who use paint.
10,137
]
No Printable Available
Yoshi Box Cover Comments
Wii » Yoshi Box Cover
← →
I started working on this since about when I comment KoopaDasher's Super Mario World box
Which is a long time(Well, for me, anyway)
Please Rate
[ Reply ]
Dude, sorry if I sound harsh, but youre a rank three now. Your boxes are not really up to standard compared to others of your rank. Your editing is really good for your rank, but your boxart needs help.
For starters, Never use just a plain gradient as a background. Secondly, the characters on the front are floating and just randomly spaced, as well as the wrong size in comparison to each other. The front is just generally not great. The back is slightly better but the yoshis are floating and that background is bad. The font is bland and hard to read.
[ Reply ]
#1, According to the post times, you commented on Koopa's box on the same day..... Try spending more time on your boxes. Like TMRD said, you have good editing skills, but your boxes aren't up to par with other Rank 3 boxes......
[ Reply ]
If the plain background doesn't work Anyone can sent me a background I can use?
[ Reply ]
Dude, your just spamming. you post a box every 1-3 days. ABD YOUR NOT GETTING BETTER!!!!! Just get a new program or quit. Seriously.
[ Reply ]
#5, LaserSonic, ignore him, you have potiental, just spend more time on your boxes ;)
[ Reply ]
#5, Huh... A rank 1 telling a rank 3 to quit?
And I'm using PhotoShop
the best program for making boxes
I did took some classes on a program similar to photoshop few years ago
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#5, Dude that's rough, you say stuff like that you'll get yourself banned because it's not nice at all.
And LaserSonic, i suggest you take a different perspective on this box, get a different background like TMRD said, I saw you post this in the WiPs and you didnt get much help with it, i love the Yoshi render on you username logo and I have to say the back is better than the front. The main problem seems to be that the pictures of the characters are all from different games so it makes the look too different graphic wise, try and find some that look similar, or try to render them, because you seem to do a good job of that :)
You need any more help on any boxes let me know because ive started taking a different perspective and mine look a lot better now.
[ Reply ]
Updated!!
better now?
[ Reply ]
#6-#8, I'm rude? You guys have no idea how many times I've been told that OK. It's just not a good box. Spend more time. OK thats all I'm saying. And be more creative, take a daring plunge, which may get you better. And the only reason I'm a rank 1 is because I only have like 6 boxes, your a rank 3 because of all your boxes.
[ Reply ]
#10, It's not like you spend more time on YOUR box than mine
[ Reply ]
#10, LaserSonic has some really good boxes!
[ Reply ]
#12, First time EVER heard that
Thank You
[ Reply ]
#10, Yeah you're rude, your telling him to quite making boxarts, without even trying to help him out on improve. You're generally not a very nice person to people who are putting a lot of effort into their boxes if their boxes aren't very good.
The update is better, especially the back, how about finding a background for the front instead of just something on the bottom where they're standing. I say get rid of the solid color on the background of the front, i think this could become a good box.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Updated with a background...
[ Reply ]
#10, Those kind of comments such as, "Just get a new program or quit. Seriously" can be taken as breaking the "Constructive criticism" rule and you will receive a ban. I'm not sure who told you the same thing but if they did they were also in the wrong. Saying those comments do not help others improve and it is taken very seriously by the administrator and the moderators. If you have a problem with someone making rude comments toward yourself please take it up with one of the moderators in PMs.
[ Reply ]
Yeah LaserSonic this looks a lot better with the new background on the front, but theres 2 renders of yoshi on the front, which is one too many.
[ Reply ]
#16, It was spypilot. I know my box wasn't very good but here it is so you can see the comment:http://vgboxart.com/view/33584/da.banana.bunch/?replies=3
[ Reply ]
#18, I agree that Spypilot shouldn't have said that but does it make it right that you said it to someone else? No.
[ Reply ]
The box is WAY better now! Fav ;)
[ Reply ]
#18, Yeah... spypilot does that, but he's higher rank than you
#20, Thanks
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#21, Rank has nothing to do with how you can treat a fellow user. This is the exact reason why I am a advocate of removing the entire rank system because it encourages elitist attitudes. The fact is every member, no matter the rank, needs to be respectful of every other member. Otherwise, how will we improve as a site?
[ Reply ]
#2, the ranks do say nothing about the skill of the artist here.
about the box: your big signature and the credits distract from your work. make it smaller and put it more in the background 'cause the page is about the box, not the credits and signatures. (this doesn't mean you should not post it on your stuff, just not like you do here)
[ Reply ]
#5, and youre the one to say that?
lol, i just about died laughing.
also, i didnt go out harsh, i said to just stop posting them, no one said anything about stopping to make em. sorry i just have problems with users (besides shadowdialga) who use paint.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
We should really stop discussing this or all of us is gonna get banned(maybe not)
#24, How's the box, spypilot?
[ Reply ]