#3, It's not anything amazing, but it is good. So he used the Robotnik from the official box, so what? It's a good looking template, a decent art comp, and everything looks clean. I don't think Skyrunner deserves you telling him he just "slapped" things on. It's not entirely creative, but it works. I stand by my comment.
RB, Yeah so? I used PART of the original cover. So what? Its not like I slapped the wallpaper on with some dev logos and called it my own. It's not the same sonic redner either, so therefore there's no problem with this. It's not stolen, and this was just a front-only comp box. ?
I didn't use the official logo because Im trying to try something new maybe? Tleeart, Spiderpig, and Glowblue thanks.
Nothin much.
Just my comp box against Stinkynelkin for round 1 in the Retro Comp.
#2 Thanks man.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
I'd put a stroke or drop shadow on the logo text, but I like it.
[ Reply ]
#2, i don't, as a matter of fact, it's the official 3rd one, temp slapped on a part of the official one, threw in sonic, and a logo, see: link
[ Reply ]
One Sonic game I don't have for the Genesis, I think it looks great. +fav
[ Reply ]
#3, It's not anything amazing, but it is good. So he used the Robotnik from the official box, so what? It's a good looking template, a decent art comp, and everything looks clean. I don't think Skyrunner deserves you telling him he just "slapped" things on. It's not entirely creative, but it works. I stand by my comment.
[ Reply ]
#5, look closer, robotnik is in the same place on the official as the one here
[ Reply ]
#6, Yeah, because the art ends there, he'd have to recreate art that isn't there, unless he had a render of that art before it was placed.
I'm not claiming he didn't use the art from the original box.
[ Reply ]
#7, ... thats what post #6 was about, i thought you did claim that he didn't use the official art
[ Reply ]
#8, Naw, I was just saying he didn't just slap it on there, he at least thought of a way to still make it look good.
[ Reply ]
Is it against the rules of the comp to use any official art? If not, I don't see the problem with this.
[ Reply ]
#9, it'd look good, but with the fusing the 2 kinds of art... and why didn't he use the official logo?
[ Reply ]
RB, Yeah so? I used PART of the original cover. So what? Its not like I slapped the wallpaper on with some dev logos and called it my own. It's not the same sonic redner either, so therefore there's no problem with this. It's not stolen, and this was just a front-only comp box. ?
I didn't use the official logo because Im trying to try something new maybe? Tleeart, Spiderpig, and Glowblue thanks.
[ Reply ]