Hall of Fame?! No, I don't think so. Let me explain why.
First of all, the joke never was, isn't now, and never will be funny. Plus, the front just isn't right. What are the crystals doing there? Why does Sonic look so weird with that effect like he's moving? What's up with the logo, and with that I mean the word 'Super' and the 'C' at the end of 'Sonic'. Also, the Sonic on the top (of the back) overlays the template, and maybe some like it, but that way it quickly loses its authenticity.
And finally, why don't you come up with an idea that is original and no one ever did before (I know, some of you are probably thinking of my The Orange's Box, but I never knew of any other box with that joke)? In terms of finetuning this actually IS your best box, though that wouldn't really count as a compliment, when I'm looking at a couple of your boxes, like Zelda: Four Spoons Adventures, Zelda: Twilight Princess 2 and ESPECIALLY your Halo 3 cover. Don't get me wrong, you're improving, and this is a bit of a step forward at finetuning, but next time, come up with a neat idea, much less blur or whatever it's called effects and just make it less chaotic.
Thinking of everything I said above, I'd give it a 6/10. You have talent, and I think you can be just as good as say, ELCrazy or KoopaDasher.
#7, Sheesh, way to look like you know it all. Which you don't.
The box is actually not too shabby as Vengeance said. MAJOR improvement over your other boxes. But it could still use some work. The logo is kind of stretched and you could probably have a better one, if a member would be so kind to do so (I'd do it but I'm a bit busy for the next few days.) the back is really nice and has an official feel to it. The text and screen borders could do with some smoothing. But that's about it. While the idea is over done, this box has some potential IMO =)
You know, I actually like this one. Kinda makes me wish I did a back on mine. Anyways, the only thing I don't really like is the logo, other than that it is pretty good.
I like it and its your best so far but I dont think its worthy of a HoF IMO.
I mean its nice but there are some flaws that really turn me off it.
- The Disc is far too small compared to the box
- The logo looks stretched and theres something odd about it
- There is no ESRB on the front (or if there is, it must be VERY small to be blocked completley by the disc)
- I dont like how it appears Sonic is just randomly floating through space
- Missing legal info on the back and the back ESRB is too bold
- Solar Sonic and Darkspine Sonic are sorta lame, sorry.
- I dont like the Sonic on the back going over the template
- I dont get why half the description is in French?
Sorry if it sounds like im being too harsh or nitpicky, but those are the reasons I dont like as much as other people. It just seemed like some people only faved this because its your best yet and not because they actually really, really like the box. Could be wrong though,
#27, look at the official back of Mario Galaxy. Also, ESRB is covered by the disc, logo is not stretched, but edited, and Darkspine Sonic is actually a character in Sonic and the Secret Rings. Solar Sonic is my idea. Sorry you don't like it.
#28 Read properly. I never said I dont like it, I said there are a few flaws that stop me faving it. And I am looking at the official back of Super Mario Galaxy (holding in my hand) and there is no French and there is nothing going over the template? So whats your point?
And if the ESRB is 100% covered by the disc, then the ESRB is too small and badly placed too high.
Almost really good. Nice lay-out, it's almost there. But a lot of stuff is messed up (Little blue lines here and there on the front, logo looks weird with transparency and the ring, the little emeralds next to the header on the back look bad compared to the realistic feel of the rest). Otherwise, you're really getting there. :D The screenshots are nice, and so is most of the front and the back. Nice font choice and that little box is pretty cool. Just move all that text+box thing up a little, you have a blank space sitting there. Oh, and the Sonic on the back with the whip thing around him looks unrealistic-- take off the SMG swirl thing and it'll look better. I suggest coming back to this once you get better, it definitely has potential :)
7/10 way tooooooooo clutttteeeeered... Also, Text Layers are not anything to be proud of. Sonic (on the back) is going into the template, and the blur effect just looks bad here. Why did you use a GameCube CD for the CD template?
ok update with :My own logo
Better solar and darkspine renders
all 7 emeralds visable
and sonic is in the temp more
better?
PS i didnt have a better place for the disc so i had to skew it.
#65, thanks but your not gonna kill me are ya? i gave you that logo. lol
#67, i know whats up with that?
#79 47 and counting. It's because too many random n00bs favorited it because it's a Sonic box. It doesn't get HOF that way. That's what happened to my box... :|
And too anyone who attacks me, I shall not be denied!
No, I think this actually deserves HoF...the new version anyway. Old version, not so much. And it's NOT just because it's Sonic, cuz I actually hate this idea with a passion. HOWEVER, that's not to say it's not a very well executed idea. The ONLY flaw I can really see would be Sonic overlapping the template...and even that looks COOL, just not PROFESSIONAL. +1 Fave
I won't fav it but it's nice. Anyone could easily say this doesn't deserve as many favs as other boxes, but none of you can determine exactly how many favs these should receive. It's quite pointless to try. I dislike these backlashes, that are because some people don't like it as much as others and because it got in the Hall.
Hmmm its pretty well made and i love the back but the design of the front to me is just plain bad and i cant imagine seeing it in stores sorry and also the sega logo is overlaping the game logo which dosent look too good if you ask me.
Some comments:
- I thought the co-op text on version 3 looked better
- Shadow and Silver are a bit random placed
- Characters on planet are too big
- Maybe add some effects to the Green Hill-planet?
- Give the borders on the back a more sprinkling/shiny feel
- I hope these are good suggestions!
#124 NEEDS TO GET NOTICED MORE?! This box has 124 comments, 114 favs and 34,490 views?! Yet you reckon this box needs to get noticed more?! Oh, alright then...
Ok here it is.Credit too Ninty for the Logo(Kinda).
[ Reply ]
Thats pretty tight good job fav+
[ Reply ]
as much as i hate the idea, and these type of boxes, i have to say this aint too shabby.
[ Reply ]
you know, this is your best, no doubt
[ Reply ]
Damn, I love this. this could be a HOF.
[ Reply ]
#4, Ya definitly.This took a month and there is over 60 layers on it.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Hall of Fame?! No, I don't think so. Let me explain why.
First of all, the joke never was, isn't now, and never will be funny. Plus, the front just isn't right. What are the crystals doing there? Why does Sonic look so weird with that effect like he's moving? What's up with the logo, and with that I mean the word 'Super' and the 'C' at the end of 'Sonic'. Also, the Sonic on the top (of the back) overlays the template, and maybe some like it, but that way it quickly loses its authenticity.
And finally, why don't you come up with an idea that is original and no one ever did before (I know, some of you are probably thinking of my The Orange's Box, but I never knew of any other box with that joke)? In terms of finetuning this actually IS your best box, though that wouldn't really count as a compliment, when I'm looking at a couple of your boxes, like Zelda: Four Spoons Adventures, Zelda: Twilight Princess 2 and ESPECIALLY your Halo 3 cover. Don't get me wrong, you're improving, and this is a bit of a step forward at finetuning, but next time, come up with a neat idea, much less blur or whatever it's called effects and just make it less chaotic.
Thinking of everything I said above, I'd give it a 6/10. You have talent, and I think you can be just as good as say, ELCrazy or KoopaDasher.
[ Reply ]
#7, it's... not a joke...
#6, yeah, I believe that. *Rolls eyes*
[ Reply ]
#7, Sheesh, way to look like you know it all. Which you don't.
The box is actually not too shabby as Vengeance said. MAJOR improvement over your other boxes. But it could still use some work. The logo is kind of stretched and you could probably have a better one, if a member would be so kind to do so (I'd do it but I'm a bit busy for the next few days.) the back is really nice and has an official feel to it. The text and screen borders could do with some smoothing. But that's about it. While the idea is over done, this box has some potential IMO =)
[ Reply ]
0__________o THAT IS THE BEST SONIC BOX I'VE SEEN IN MY ENTIRE LIFE!!!
10/10!
YOU ROCK!
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#8, I has over 60 layers i swear
#7 Whatever BTW the "crystals" are emerald shards and the blur is because he is flying.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Your best, and possibly, best sonic galaxy or galaxy spinoff box on site. +fav
[ Reply ]
#12, thanks
[ Reply ]
#7:
"What's up with the logo, and with that I mean the word 'Super' and the 'C' at the end of 'Sonic'"
I think its a ring.
"Also, the Sonic on the top (of the back) overlays the template"
I dont realy like that either, but i can oversee tharl
#15, I gueaaed go.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#14, It so it dosnt look like Ninty logo
[ Reply ]
should be a HoF
[ Reply ]
You know, I actually like this one. Kinda makes me wish I did a back on mine. Anyways, the only thing I don't really like is the logo, other than that it is pretty good.
[ Reply ]
#17, thanks man, I really like yours.
[ Reply ]
Huge improvement from your other boxes. Good job.
[ Reply ]
Your best by FAR.
[ Reply ]
DEFENETLY your best. 50000000000000000000000000000000000/5. just one question why is there only 5 emeralds?
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
how the living hell, did you make those super sonics? can you pm me them? please, i'll credit!
[ Reply ]
#21, dunno
#22, with tons of skill. (phtoshop).
would all those who faved please comment
#24, kthnx.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#23, it's a freakin piece of art. nuff said
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Obviously your best. Keep it up for a first HOF.
[ Reply ]
#25, I hope.
[ Reply ]
I like it and its your best so far but I dont think its worthy of a HoF IMO.
I mean its nice but there are some flaws that really turn me off it.
- The Disc is far too small compared to the box
- The logo looks stretched and theres something odd about it
- There is no ESRB on the front (or if there is, it must be VERY small to be blocked completley by the disc)
- I dont like how it appears Sonic is just randomly floating through space
- Missing legal info on the back and the back ESRB is too bold
- Solar Sonic and Darkspine Sonic are sorta lame, sorry.
- I dont like the Sonic on the back going over the template
- I dont get why half the description is in French?
Sorry if it sounds like im being too harsh or nitpicky, but those are the reasons I dont like as much as other people. It just seemed like some people only faved this because its your best yet and not because they actually really, really like the box. Could be wrong though,
Still, great job =]
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#27, look at the official back of Mario Galaxy. Also, ESRB is covered by the disc, logo is not stretched, but edited, and Darkspine Sonic is actually a character in Sonic and the Secret Rings. Solar Sonic is my idea. Sorry you don't like it.
[ Reply ]
#28 Read properly. I never said I dont like it, I said there are a few flaws that stop me faving it. And I am looking at the official back of Super Mario Galaxy (holding in my hand) and there is no French and there is nothing going over the template? So whats your point?
And if the ESRB is 100% covered by the disc, then the ESRB is too small and badly placed too high.
[ Reply ]
This is perfect
[ Reply ]
#29, PAL version? because on the american version, there is french.
#32, no problem. the french was the hardest part of doing it. we cool?
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#31 Oh seriously?? Oh I didnt know that. Sorry about that then.
[ Reply ]
I'm unsure, but I think this box only needs 30 more points! (i counted 70)
[ Reply ]
Come on HOF. Come ON HOF. COME ON HOF!!
#35, sorry, but could not edit. Sorry about that TTT.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#33 and #34, please don't bump, it's extremely annoying.
[ Reply ]
Almost really good. Nice lay-out, it's almost there. But a lot of stuff is messed up (Little blue lines here and there on the front, logo looks weird with transparency and the ring, the little emeralds next to the header on the back look bad compared to the realistic feel of the rest). Otherwise, you're really getting there. :D The screenshots are nice, and so is most of the front and the back. Nice font choice and that little box is pretty cool. Just move all that text+box thing up a little, you have a blank space sitting there. Oh, and the Sonic on the back with the whip thing around him looks unrealistic-- take off the SMG swirl thing and it'll look better. I suggest coming back to this once you get better, it definitely has potential :)
Wait, why's it Spanish? O.o
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#36, its French, and The back is Identical to the layout of Super Mario Galaxy, and I'm not changing it yet.
Sorry about the bump, couldnt edit.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
lol, nearly hof!(at 91 points atm(i think)
[ Reply ]
#38, REALLY?
[ Reply ]
#39, just take deeeeep breaths, TTT... deeep breaths...
[ Reply ]
#40, WTF?
If you don't like it, don't comment.
[ Reply ]
#41, it's not the box, it's your constant bumping. Seriously, stop it.
[ Reply ]
You make those renders? If you did, collio, if you did not: CURSE YOU.
[ Reply ]
#43, yes i did
[ Reply ]
nice darkspine sonic
[ Reply ]
omg! nearly hof! nice box 5/5! ill fave to get you closer :)
what ive counted 98 points!
sincerely a_masta
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
If it was 98 it should be 101 now! :D
[ Reply ]
PLZ PM ME THE SUPER SONICS!!!! i will give you any of my FUTURE creations.. :)
[ Reply ]
7/10 way tooooooooo clutttteeeeered... Also, Text Layers are not anything to be proud of. Sonic (on the back) is going into the template, and the blur effect just looks bad here. Why did you use a GameCube CD for the CD template?
I really hop the HOF doesn't have/Get this.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#49 I agree. There are way too many flaws for this to get into the HoF.
[ Reply ]
#50, that doesn't matter. It's the people, not the box that decides weather it goes into the HoF or not.
[ Reply ]
#51 So? You think I dont know that? Doesn't stop me giving my opinion.
[ Reply ]
#49, i dont have a Wii disc temp so i had to make one from scrach. #54, Well sorry but as you may have notised. you only have 1h to edit
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#50, Agreed. Way too many flaws.
#53, Quit bumping.
[ Reply ]
#53 The Wii doesn't use a template for the CDs... it just says wii on the left... re rest is just like a normal CD or DVD
[ Reply ]
didnt know thatat that time because i didnt have a Wii
EDIT: Did i count right? 114 Points?
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#56, didn't Have a wii? You don't a Wii? Don't get one, unless you like kid games.
Points I count out to about 110.
EDIT: Check your PMs.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#56, Check PMs. I think I have A grid.
[ Reply ]
IF this was a real game I would buy it and wouldn't go to sleep until I had completed it. +fav
[ Reply ]
#59 Now thats a sign of a TRUE Sonic fan XD
[ Reply ]
#60, ya thats either a sign of true fandom or crazyness.
[ Reply ]
ok, the total picture is nice,but when you look in detail, you see ALOT of major and minor errors that don't please me.. at all.
Oh, and good job at not taking a criticism, hence the fact i will not give a complete comment.
[ Reply ]
#62, =D
[ Reply ]
The box i awesome!!!
Its just that Darkspine Sonic is squished a little bit.
other than that,4/5
[ Reply ]
cool box
[ Reply ]
ok update with :My own logo
Better solar and darkspine renders
all 7 emeralds visable
and sonic is in the temp more
better?
PS i didnt have a better place for the disc so i had to skew it.
#65, thanks but your not gonna kill me are ya? i gave you that logo. lol
#67, i know whats up with that?
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
122 faves, but no HOF?
[ Reply ]
I honestly hope this dosen't make Hall of Fame. the logo looked better the other way, not like this style.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#67, my SSX box has 127 but no HoF. its wierd.
[ Reply ]
THEY SHOULD MAKE THIS!!!
[ Reply ]
#69 same here with my Starfox Assault
[ Reply ]
#68, why because i made it?
#70, ya sure
#73, now you too? great then i must suck at logos
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#67 you mean points right?
#72 That logo really is bad dude.
There is obviously something Reed isn't telling us. I think he hasn't said what because it would make the boxes harder to get into the HOF.
#74 Get off my case already. It isn't the "best box" on VGBA so I'm giving him criticism and stating something else in the process.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#73, For the love of God, STOP BUMPING THIS
[ Reply ]
#74, Wow. For once I agree with you.
[ Reply ]
lol sega will make something similar to mario galaxy.
[ Reply ]
God!! Is this the box that just WONT die!! >.<
[ Reply ]
that is the best supermariogalaxy of sonic i've seen.don't forget dark super sonic
[ Reply ]
ROFL 43 favs yet no HoF
[ Reply ]
#79 47 and counting. It's because too many random n00bs favorited it because it's a Sonic box. It doesn't get HOF that way. That's what happened to my box... :|
And too anyone who attacks me, I shall not be denied!
[ Reply ]
#80, true, but I will attack You anyways!
[ Reply ]
This seriously better not get HoF, still to many flaws.
Greaaat, 127 points =/
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Grats for the Hall, but I liked the other logo better.
[ Reply ]
Congratz.
[ Reply ]
no. NO! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!
I mean, this was bound to happen one day! I just didnt think i'd be alive to see it :(
Congrats noneoftheless.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Finally! Congrats Sonic.
#88 How about one for each rank.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Hall of Fame? pfft... i'm sorry, but this is a prime example of why the fav requirements should be like, 50.
[ Reply ]
#87, Or why you should have at least one rank nine fave it before it gets in the Hall.
We have enough by now that I think that's a fair requirement.
[ Reply ]
I hope Jevangod and Mugglesman are proud of themselves.
[ Reply ]
Ahg! No, HoF system should be upgraded, and harder to get.
[ Reply ]
i like the older logo
[ Reply ]
No, I think this actually deserves HoF...the new version anyway. Old version, not so much. And it's NOT just because it's Sonic, cuz I actually hate this idea with a passion. HOWEVER, that's not to say it's not a very well executed idea. The ONLY flaw I can really see would be Sonic overlapping the template...and even that looks COOL, just not PROFESSIONAL. +1 Fave
[ Reply ]
emmm......... congratz on first hof!
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#89, We know they can fav what they want.
I won't fav it but it's nice. Anyone could easily say this doesn't deserve as many favs as other boxes, but none of you can determine exactly how many favs these should receive. It's quite pointless to try. I dislike these backlashes, that are because some people don't like it as much as others and because it got in the Hall.
[ Reply ]
you know, i am pleasently suprised at this, great job! i think that i am going to fav this.
[ Reply ]
thats pretty kool 5/5
[ Reply ]
Well, I may not like the Logo. Congratulations Sonic.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
YES ITS IN THE HALL! :) thanks guys ill never forget this :D
[ Reply ]
#98, Listen, We get it, Its in the Hall! and no problem.
Also, Check your PMs.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
100th comment!
very nice!
ill fav. :)
[ Reply ]
congrats on the first hof.
[ Reply ]
Everything looks alot better now that you fixed it. Congrats on the HOF, you deserve it.
[ Reply ]
#66, HI
[ Reply ]
#103, *facepalm* why did you have too bump like that?!?
#101&102 well thanks
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Omg, this is pure awesomeness...I need help with my Sonic ones, can you help?
[ Reply ]
this box is amazing.
[ Reply ]
#106, gee thanx :)
anyways i updated with the BEST logo i could make
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Get FIREFOX!!
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Pulled something right out of the bag! Love it!
[ Reply ]
Hmmm its pretty well made and i love the back but the design of the front to me is just plain bad and i cant imagine seeing it in stores sorry and also the sega logo is overlaping the game logo which dosent look too good if you ask me.
[ Reply ]
can u give me a link for the logo plz
5/5 +fav
[ Reply ]
#111, i never posted the logo anywhere...i can get it to you next week though
[ Reply ]
This is amazing. Out of this world. 5/5 +fav
[ Reply ]
Awsome, definate fav.
[ Reply ]
THIS IS FREAKING AWESOME!!!! 1000/1000. FAV!
[ Reply ]
the new one is even better 1,000,000,000/1,000,000,000! I wish I could fave this twice.
[ Reply ]
Some comments:
- I thought the co-op text on version 3 looked better
- Shadow and Silver are a bit random placed
- Characters on planet are too big
- Maybe add some effects to the Green Hill-planet?
- Give the borders on the back a more sprinkling/shiny feel
- I hope these are good suggestions!
[ Reply ]
#116, thanx :D
#117, i'll see what i can do
[ Reply ]
Nice box, bad idea. Might as well fav.
[ Reply ]
I LOVE ALL YOUR WORK! :)
[ Reply ]
Isn't it ironic that there are 99 faves and still no masterworks?
[ Reply ]
#121, 100 now :)
But the reason it's not in is because of all the "n00bs" who faved it.
[ Reply ]
COOL BOX fav+
[ Reply ]
THIS MUST BE MASTERWORKS NOW! IT NEEDS TO GET NOTICED MORE!
[ Reply ]
#124 NEEDS TO GET NOTICED MORE?! This box has 124 comments, 114 favs and 34,490 views?! Yet you reckon this box needs to get noticed more?! Oh, alright then...
[ Reply ]
I like this a lot
[ Reply ]
#61, same with me, i completed sonic adventure in one day non stop
[ Reply ]
This is ok, but the logo on the front needs moving up, it doesn't look good there :(
[ Reply ]
FUCKING HELL!!! This should've been a masterwork piece
This mustve tooken you a hell lotta time to make
great job once again sonic!!!
10/5
[ Reply ]
is it a masterworks yet? DAMMIT VGBOXART! PERFECT BOX ART HERE!
[ Reply ]
Amazing idea, fav+
[ Reply ]
I think for the Super sonic on the back in the Transformations section could be a bit better. Other than that I have no bad comments. Great!
[ Reply ]
Solar Sonic And Darkspine Sonic Look Nice
[ Reply ]