[ Box updated on February 22nd, 2008 ] [ original ]
Pokemon: Acanthite Box Cover Comments
Comment on VGMaster's Pokemon: Acanthite Box Art / Cover.
[ Box updated on February 22nd, 2008 ] [ original ]
Comment on VGMaster's Pokemon: Acanthite Box Art / Cover.
F**cking amazing. I love it.
[ Reply ]
Based on the fan-game Pokemon Acanthite.
Please C+C if you don't mind...
Thanx!
#1, thanks!
EDIT: Oops, forgot wi-fi logo, fixing...
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#2, oh, i mind alright!!
[ Reply ]
Really nice!
[ Reply ]
#2, fan game? Could you link to it?
[ Reply ]
awsome man amazing box.
[ Reply ]
what are those pokemon?! i've never seen those before... i really want the one on the front.
[ Reply ]
very cool.
[ Reply ]
link
Added wi-fi logo.
[ Reply ]
battle over w-fi?
nice anyway.
[ Reply ]
#9, how do I play it?
[ Reply ]
It's not playable yet I don't think...
None of the screens are actually from Acanthite, I edited one and used 2 D/P
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#12, F*CK!
[ Reply ]
i attempted a pokemon fan game but it failed.
[ Reply ]
I reckon it could be much better if the background was more appealing, for example if VGMaster played around with it so it was more like these. link
Still very good.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Pretty good, the front seems kinda plain for my liking.
Makes me want to make a box art with some of my fakemon.
[ Reply ]
I'm lovin it VGM! What E_G said, you should fiddle with the background a bit and you could have one of the coolest pokemon boxes on the site! +fav
[ Reply ]
Thanks dude. I'm not to good with effects, but I'll try.
and thanks S.J.
[ Reply ]
i think you like pokemon, am i correct? "plain" but perfect.
[ Reply ]
Give the front some kind of twinkles or something and add a background or something to the back and i would like it a lot.
[ Reply ]
You didn't give any credit to the artist. I had assumed that you drew the images yourself, until I investigated the fan game. You should know better.
Good job with the screenshots. I'm always happy to see people putting that level of detail into their boxes. I have to say that the artwork is pretty poor, and the overall design of the cover is pretty bland.
The back looks ideal, though. Pokemon boxes always have very minimalist backs to their games, much like this one.
[ Reply ]
*in Borat voice* Its nice, i like, like sexy time xD, but now more serioiusnes, i like this box ( b^.^)b
[ Reply ]
#19, thanx.
#20, I'll try.
#21, whatever. I said it was a fangame, I would have thought people would have the sense to know that someone else did it. Gimme a break!
#22, thanx
[ Reply ]
#23, Don't "whatever" me. You know as well as I do that not giving credit to an artist is art theft. You're allowing people to assume that you did that artwork yourself, and you didn't. It's YOUR job to specify that it's not yours. I expect to never see you ever complain about someone not giving credit for a logo or template, since you've done the exact same thing with this.
[ Reply ]
its the best yet 5/5 i love it the images and also im making one and its gonna be credit to u inpired by VGmaster thats the best yet and done bother saying #25, thanx say something different say like awesome thanks for that mate your the best aswell and thanks for the rate see!!!
thanks for putting that up and i will be looking forward too your next one!!!
[ Reply ]
#14, fine whatever. 'Credit to the site for the art' Happy?
Thanks Pokefan
[ Reply ]
I don't care about whether or not you do it in this instance since everyone knows it now. I just want people to be more appreciative of artists and to give credit where credit is due. I, and artists everywhere I assume, would greatly appreciate it if you'd be more conscientious of doing it in the future.
[ Reply ]
I did it ONCE! I haven't forgotten it before, I just figured people would realize I didn't do it or I would have said "MY fangame."
Please stop making me feel bad...
*hides under couch*
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
This Is The Best F*cking Box I Have Ever Seen 1000000/5
So In The Favourites
[ Reply ]
Hi, I'm Nelson, one of Acanthite's admins and is responsible for all the artworks.
I feel insulted for not being consulted about using the artworks to be used on this Boxart.
I'm not going to ask for it to be removed, but in the future please let me know if you are going to use the arts provided.
Thanks.
[ Reply ]
#30, dude I am soo sorry, I made a mental note to ask, but I completely forgot! Please forgive me! Please? I relly did mean to!
[ Reply ]
I don't believe you.
Take it down now or I'll report you.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#32, You shouldn't expect to come on this site and order a respected member what to do. You don't have enough to support an idea that he might not be telling the truth. With that kind of attitude, I for one wouldn't take your reporting seriously. VGmaster isn't the type to lie.
I think VGMaster should just specifically say who the credit belongs to and call it a day. That's how it goes.
[ Reply ]
Great job
[ Reply ]
#33, thanks man.
Here's the credit:
Credit to Pokemon Acanthite for all of the art
[ Reply ]
Really awesome box!
To make it look even better, get some of the words on the back spelled correctly, try and get the snapshots on the back to the left not to look like they're from Diamond or Pearl. Also maybe for the background on the front, get a glittery one (like off of Diamond or Pearl for example) just in the color of Acanthite.
Still looks reaaaally good to me man. 4/5 +fav.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
#36, I wanted it to look like D/P because it's on the DS. I don't care much for spelling, I will fix in some cases, but not now. There is a BG, but I'm working on something else and may come back to fix this. Still, thnx man.
[ Reply ]
Your welcome buddy.
[ Reply ]
#33, it is MY artwork and he has not asked for permission.
He is not to use my artwork or any of Pokemon Acanthite's artwork in any case.
He has not obtained permission to do so, so do not tell me what I can an can't do when it comes to not guarding my artworks.
[ Reply ]
Why arn't you removing it?
[ Reply ]
#40, are you complaining about someone advertising your game...
[ Reply ]
#40, Boxes can only be deleted within 60 minutes of posting, and like Sockey said, it's advertisement for your game, so what's the problem?
[ Reply ]
He's used art without permission.
[ Reply ]
#39 Could we maybe have some proof that shows you are really who you say you are?
Anyways, onto the box. Its great, but I dunno if the back's colours really catch the D/P style. Good box, all and all. I just really wish my Pokemon box got this much attention :[
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Well, I've ONLY got the 157 photoshop files for each art for Pokemon Acanthite's generation of Pokemon. :O
[ Reply ]
It really is him guys. I know that because I made an account on their aite a couple months ago. And I can't delete it. Besides, in your first comment, you said I didn't have to. Let your yes be yes and your no be no.
[ Reply ]
Everyone here is acting like they have the sense of an ten-year-old.
In all honesty, that probably isn't truly him. It's probably some guy that wanted to do this for kicks, or to get it taken down to spite VGMaster, and before you say anything, just because he shares the name with the administrator of another forum doesn't mean they're truly the same person. Anyone can type out "Nelson" in a name field.
Assuming it's him, though, he has every single right to demand it be taken down. It's his artwork, and if he doesn't want it being used in this method then that's his right. This isn't commercially released artwork for a game, it's someone's personal artwork that they spent a lot of time using it, and VG just took it and used it for his own purposes, which is something that few people would be okay with. Whether or not he gave "proper credit" (Which he has yet to do. And to stop you, VG, from replying with "Yuh-huh! I did just a few comments ago!" I would like to point out that saying "Credit to Pokemon Acanthite for the artwork" isn't giving any kind of credit since the game itself didn't produce the art.) and whether or not he's creating free advertisements for the game is completely irrelevant, it's about principal, not getting credit or publicity.
I'd feel the same way as Nelson, though I wouldn't have used such civilized language.
[ Reply ]
I really don't need to prove to anyone who I am, except for the fact that I have mentioned that I am Nelson from PA forums. Either take it or leave it.
VG Master, I want to apologise for my sudden abruptance, I just get annoyed when I type a mature response, then you type a panicked response.
Before you use someone else's work for your cover, gain their permission first and there won't be any problems. :)
I'm going to be joining the boxart war, so watch out. ;)
But next time, just be sure to gain permission first, and give explicit credit. EXPLICIT credit!
Have a good one fellahs.
[ Reply ]
K, thanks. I did truely mean to ask. It wasn't some "Oh crap, cover it up!" thing. I do truely admire your work (not sucking up).
So, putting all of this aside, we cool? I don't want any hard feelings. If you really want this gone, it will be, I don;t want to not be liked. =D
[ Reply ]
That's particularly why I got annoyed, with the aspect of it being a cover up response.
I definetly think we're cool now. :)
You can keep it up, it's not a problem anymore. :)
[ Reply ]
*Shakes hand* It's been nice doing buisness with you.
[ Reply ]
Can you download the fake pkmn game from the website? It have a really confusing interface...
[ Reply ]
were did you get the pics of the starter pokemon from? i might need some new ones. i only have one box and the pokemon are pretty bad.
[ Reply ]
54th Comment! just wanted 2 say that
great box 5/5
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
cool fav!
[ Reply ]
#53, Their site. Don't use without permission tho.
#54, thanks.
#55, thanks.
EDIT: Oops, 53 and 54 were awhile ago.
Edited at 1 decade ago
[ Reply ]
Great box! But the l on Pearl is missing on the back. 5/5 tho!
[ Reply ]
first, TTT< stop saying Fuck with an asterisk replacing the u. secondly stop F*cking making Pokemon boxes with names of gems i have never heard of. you should make a box for pokemon Quartz, or better yet pokemon lava rock. simplify it like that. anyway this is a very nice box if so to speak. but unfortunately, i have no clue what the hell an acanthite is. (maybe its a gem, all pokemon games are named after a gem these days)
[ Reply ]
Hey, VGM! Nice work. I'm thinking now of my own Pokemon Version...but I suck at all the y'know, backgrounds and rendering. Logos...I'm sorta ok...Can you help?
[ Reply ]
#58, no, you shut up. I can make whatever version I want. You can't tell me what to make becuase your examples are no better. If you would have read the comments you would have realized that this is someone elses real game. So shut it.
#59, PM for whatever help you need.
[ Reply ]
amazing, why isn't this in the hall of fame yet??? :) fav
[ Reply ]
#62, it's possible Reed may be able to stop boxes from reaching HOF. If he is, he may have made it unable since the whole "incident"
[ Reply ]
Wow! nice box, man! Oh, and to #58: Acanthite is a type of silver, typically an alloy including silver and a few other metals.
Huh. Didn't know I could sound so scientific.
[ Reply ]
Amaizing Box! Fav!!
[ Reply ]
why is battle mispelled and also search
[ Reply ]