Wii » Metamorphosis Box Cover ← →

3,874   0  

that's a picture from a Yu-Gi-Oh! card if the same name... you can tell the top and bottom are cut off because it's a square shape. there's no dev/rating logos and the template doesn't say Wii for some reason. I know it's not a real game but that doesn't mean you shouldnt make it look real.

[ Reply ]

#2, Did you read his comment? There's a reason he doesn't have an ESRB rating, and Flowen is likely the "developer" logo. Even if he didn't explain why there's no rating, that's a horrible critique, since conforming to a certain commercial standard has nothing to do with talented design principals.

As for the box...well, I don't condone covering a picture with filters and calling it done. Also, I think you could've picked a better image than an ugly (One of THE ugliest at that) Yu-Gi-Oh! card.

Overall not bad, especially if you're a beginner, but it could certainly use some work.

[ Reply ]

#3, i know he said it's because it's not real, that's why i said: "I know it's not a real game but that doesn't mean you shouldn't make it look real". Just saying...

[ Reply ]

My point was that things like logos and ratings aren't required to make a box look real. Some people don't want to design a box that looks like it's being commercially sold. I frequently consider creating boxes that wouldn't (Or don't, in some cases) have any kind of commercial blemishes. In my opinion it degrades the quality of it.

I apologize for whining about your comment, I just get so tired of people jumping straight to logos/ratings/etc. as a means of critiquing, when in fact it isn't. Pasting a logo in the corner of an image has nothing to do with design talent or skill.

[ Reply ]

it's cool, i know how annoying it can be when people do that.

[ Reply ]

i never said there was anything wrong with using a yu-gi-oh card. i just said you did use one. gosh, why must everyone automatically assume i'm saying the box is bad by just stating that you used one picture... jeez

[ Reply ]