game Nintendo DS » Pokemon Whirlpool Box Cover
views 56,234   favorites 7 (?)  


Pokemon Whirlpool box cover
By avatar ALM5252 1 on January 4th, 2008
print No Printable Available

comments Pokemon Whirlpool Box Cover Comments


Comment on ALM5252's Pokemon Whirlpool Box Art / Cover.

avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

This is a remake of Silver for the GBC.
yes, i did use paint sadly. =_=
but i think i did do a good job...."i think." but i wanna see wut u all think.
plz tell me how i can improve. and sorry for the wrong kind of text to have the version in.

note: i do NOT have photoshop or any other type of program and i do NOT own pokemon.

[ Reply ]


avatar
VGMaster 42 [ 1 decade ago ]

Woah. That's pretty cool. Only problem is the logo. Pokemmon is cut out badly and the 'Whirlpool Version' looks bad. May I suggest another font? Very nice for a first. Welcome to VGBA!

EDIT: For what I said about the font: I didn't see post 1. when I got onto the page, you hadn't said it yet.

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]


avatar
StinkyNelkin 30 [ 1 decade ago ]

This is awesome, seriously awesome, logos a tad blurry, but it ok....4/5+fav

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

thanks. ive spent like 1hr trying to find the text to type the verion type. but no luck. -_- if any of u know where to get the text, i'd appreciate it if u culd tell me where to get it. and i got the logo from pokemon pearl. sorry it was blurry.

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

oh, the logo is both cut out badly and not. the white thing around it is the little light thing that shines from it on the diamond and peal logo. i wanted to add it in so i cut around that.

[ Reply ]


avatar
VGMaster 42 [ 1 decade ago ]

#4, try going to the MugglesMans111, XIAMHUNTERx, VGMaster, LK, ect. logo thread and I'll make you one. But request VGM or Jevangod may steal my buisness. Note, I have school tomorrow.

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

#6 ok. i'll do that, thanks. ^^ now i can be a better box designer.......except i need to use paint sadly. =_=

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]


avatar
TheSlyder 41 [ 1 decade ago ]

#1, did you create the artwork yourself, or did you just take someone else's fanart and paste it onto a template?

[ Reply ]


avatar
hsoldier 44 [ 1 decade ago ]

very nice 3/5

[ Reply ]


avatar
Vengeance 40 [ 1 decade ago ]

did you make that art? if not, give credit for it.

[ Reply ]


avatar
E-FlowGFX 29 [ 1 decade ago ]

its just a wallpaper with pokemon whirlpool version on it, and i would name it shiny silver for that fact, because red was made into fire red and i made yellow into shocking yellow =p, its good for a first but try not to use wallpapers.

WELCOME TO VGBA!!!

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

no i didnt make it. i found it on google. it didnt say who made it, but i know he deserves the credit too. ^^ but i did think about this game since Emerald version 1st came out. i plan on making a hack version of pearl to make this. Im also gonna go for another boxart called, "Pokemon Rainbow". but thanks for the comments. and its not a wallpaper, it was a really small picture of just lugia swimming around. you can find it on google, the third page (i think) if you type in "Lugia". i had to resize it. and i named it whirlpool because lugia makes whirlpools. and the other ones called rainbow because ho-oh makes rainbows. i think that makes perfect sense for the game name.

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]


avatar
E-FlowGFX 29 [ 1 decade ago ]

#12, iight i got u, and go comment my pokemon box!!!!

[ Reply ]


avatar
snake-fighter 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

this one looks very nice indeed.
try to edit the pokemon logo and an other font for the Whirlpool Edition and it's perfect.
nice background btw.
4,5/5 + Fav

[ Reply ]


avatar
Backfall Genius 7 [ 1 decade ago ]

The games are named after GEMSTONES. This one doesn't look "realistic" and I agree with #12.

[ Reply ]


avatar
TrevOwnz 42 [ 1 decade ago ]

Whirlpool could look more official and the background could to but other than that its cool.

[ Reply ]


avatar
Ranmakuu 15 [ 1 decade ago ]

This is really good

5/5

[ Reply ]


avatar
StinkyNelkin 30 [ 1 decade ago ]

Ok, #15, so is RED a gemstone? How bout' blue.

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

#16, yeah i was just thinking of putting that, but nah. thanx for the support though StinkyNelkin. :D

[ Reply ]


avatar
TwistedTinkerToy 43 [ 1 decade ago ]

You didn't make this box?

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

yeah i made the box. not the pic though. does that matter? i said it didnt have a name of the original creator, if it did i wuld have gave him/her credit. but i did think of the whole idea in general. plus i thought ur suposed to judge on how it is. atleast thats wut i keep reading around on this site.

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]


avatar
TheSlyder 41 [ 1 decade ago ]

While it's acceptable to do what you did, not giving credit (Or at least not stating that you didn't draw it yourself) is allowing everyone to believe that you did (Even if that wasn't your intent.)

Just remember that if you use someone else's artwork, it's important to give them credit, and if you don't know the artist, at least let everyone know where you found it, and that it isn't yours.

On to the title itself, it's okay, but Groudon doesn't make Rubies, Kyogre doesn't make Saphires, and while Venusaur and Charizard do make grass/fire, to an extent, they're both general elements, if you're going by that pattern, something like "water Silver."

To be honest though, I'd recommend just trying something other than Whirlpool and Rainbow. I'd try to find something that's silver, and something that's gold (Grass is green, fire is red, etc.)

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

i did state the artwork isnt mine, and i did say he/she deserves the credit too. and im not changing the name. i think its alittle dumb to name a game "ShinyGold", but still. i get wut you're saying. But since it was my idea from a long time ago, i wanted to keep it. and "Water Silver" doesnt make very good sense for a name in my opinion.

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]


avatar
TheSlyder 41 [ 1 decade ago ]

You didn't state that the artwork wasn't yours until you were confronted about it. All I'm asking is that in the future, you state it from the beginning.

Anyway, being the nostalgic, sentimental fool that I am, I support your decision on the title. If something's important to you, by all means go with it.

[ Reply ]


avatar
ALM5252 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

well i thought i stated it. sorry. but i plan on fixing this one up wen i get the programs for it and text.

[ Reply ]


avatar
joshual2153 3 [ 1 decade ago ]

wow very good. you should make the back of the box. that would be awsome. 6/5!

[ Reply ]


avatar
Mew59 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

Nice Box!! 5/5= Me Likey 100%! Fav!!:)

[ Reply ]


avatar
MachHedgehog 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

dude this is aswome !

[ Reply ]


avatar
Gomez24 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

Wow! I like the text you used for the "Whirlpool Version" part. The pic of Lugia is pretty cool, too.

Oh, and to "TheSlyder"; Lighten up! Everyone obviously knows that he didn't actually draw it! (I'm not trying to say that you couldn't) Cut the guy some slack!

[ Reply ]


avatar
ShyAngel 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

TheSlyder:You didn't state that the artwork wasn't yours until you were confronted about it. All I'm asking is that in the future, you state it from the beginning.

Anyway, being the nostalgic, sentimental fool that I am, I support your decision on the title. If something's important to you, by all means go with it.

ShyAngel:Why keep on complaining about what this artist did. He just created something & he did it nice. There's nothing wrong with using someone's art picture, & yes, it's true you should let the artist know about it. But...you forget that everyone is still learning to draw really well or perfect. Not everybody has the excellent talent for ART. So if I were you, I would accept the fact that this artist made a mistake when he didn't add in saying that he found it somewhere on Google. If I made a mistake, I would expect someone to politely ask if he/she made it or got the picture from somewhere if "it" doesn't look original.

To ALM5252...Don't worry about what TheSlyder said. I like you idea of this box. And good luck with finding the best paint ever!

[ Reply ]


avatar
Slippythetoad 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

you can do this kinda work on paint! jeez im horrible on paint and its all i have and mine come out horrible thats why i dont want to upload mine

[ Reply ]