VGBA Duel: MugglesMan111 vs. frenchboy1

[MugglesMan111]

The rules were to create a box for a platformer game so heres the boxes!


frenchboy1:




MugglesMan111:


First to 7 votes by tomorow night at 8pm EST is the winner of this duel

Mugglesman:///////
frenchboy1:/------

MugglesMan111 wins the duel!

[MugglesMan111]

oh and credit to Techne for the temp on my box

[Moogle]

Muggles, because its crisp and clean and it presents itself nicely.
I dont like Frenchboys because the giant ZOOM in on mario isnt appealing and the text on the back doesnt look good + the Lumas are poor quality.

[yummybrains]

Frenchboy1
Pros:
Original Front
Cool Screenshots

Cons:
Layout of The Back In General
Strange Light On The Front




Mugglesman
Pros:
Great Back Overall
Great Front Overall

Cons:
Sorta Busy Front
Small Nintendo logo

All In All I Vote For Mugglesman, Fb1's box is great but mm111's just stands out and is better than official.

[Kirbylore]

ooh! Mugglesman111 has my vote!, i don't like the zoom in on fenchboys....

[frenchboy1]

lol Already 3-0... Great work Muggle, you'll probably win... Unless 7 people vote for me *creating alternates accounts*



joke, E_G, calm down XD

[MugglesMan111]

lol Already 3-0... Great work Muggle, you'll probably win... Unless 7 people vote for me *creating alternates accounts*



joke, E_G, calm down XD

lol be optimistic dude

[frenchboy1]

lol be optimistic dude

lol yeah, you're right, each of these boxes have 4 faves by now, that just make me hoping

[VGMaster]

I REALLY cannot decide. I wanna vote for MM111 becuase he's my friend and his box is good and I wanna vote for FB1 because his looks good too!

I'm gonna vote for...

Mugglesman111

I like the front cuz it's well designed and so is the back. Now excuse me while I go favorite Fb1's too.

[GuitarMan]

My vote goes to FB1. i like the orignal stye yet he should make it a special edition. fits the vibe of the box.

i also really liked mm111's a lot. so i flipped a coin because i couldnt decide.

[E_G]

I don't have much to add. They are both well conceived box arts and I don't like the zoom in on FB1's box art either.

I vote for MugglesMan111.

[DrDoomsday]

Tough descision, but in the end, I'll have to go with...

MugglesMan111. I like the clean, fresh style. frenchboy's was still good though. Keep up the good work.

[Lenny819]

defently Mugglesman111's box. IT looks Fantastic and the SMG box looks bad. Front looks werid and back is horrible especialy when it says boo mario ,spring mario and bee mario, thats so ovious.