Feed Vs. Alldreamsfalldown

[Roboross]

[susuwatari]

--------------------

[alldreamsfalldown]

There. Was that so hard?

[Feed]

word word word

[dmshaposv]

I'm def confused on this one. Both aren't the best boxes made by their respective artists.

Alldream's box has an excellent front cover. I personally like the mysterious "cold" effect and the water ripples underneath the 3 look perfect. It's more eye-catching than Feed's front cover, TBH. I also love what alldreams did with the logo, looks better than the official one.

The back cover however, kinda ruins it. The colder, mysterious theme is here but the text warp effect doesn't look too snazzy. Not that it shouldn't be there, but it should have been less exaggerated. Also, your legal info part on most of your boxes is very low-res and blurry. You really need to make sure that everything compliments the high-res look of your box, even that not-so-important legal info.


Feed's box goes on a different tangent. It has a "hot" sweltering feel. The hellish images are nice, and I like the angle of the building on the front cover but not too fond of the extra dial behind the girl. The back is better than alldreams's, in that its more inspired and higher-res but the grunge effects around the screens are over-done.

Now I'm confused what is the true style of the game - "hellish and hot" or "cold and mysterious". I've never played a clock tower game in my life so I can't judge which artist has caught on the style of the game well.

[Feed]

Thats what i call "comparing two boxes"

[Dark_Shadow]

well both are very good but ADFD's one doesn't have the stylish text of all horror game on his back and I think that it's an important thing for an horror box.. so I must go with feed's one

[Radioactive Bob]

Wow, this is tough. I'm going to have to vote for Alldreamsfalldown on this on.

I love the front, the water drop under the logo is just so creative and cool. And while the back's text may be a bit plain, on the other hand it's a bit difficult to read the text on Feed's box.

So while both boxes are awesome, ADFD got my attention with his mystery-focused design more then the fiery effects used by Feed.

[alldreamsfalldown]

Wha!....Ooh votes

[Ayron]

ok,, this is a tough one

Feeds box:
the 'falling girl' look definetly caught my eye, and the fiery brushes made it work imo,but,the huge white clock kinda ruins it for me,TBH, it would alot better with a bit more 'grunge'look, like the rest of the box.. the back is Pretty nice, but, as DMs said, these boxes are not the best of their respective artists,,.
the screenshots on the back also had me blink my eyes twice, since i couldn't see clearly what was going on[ with the border ],
But the blending is superb here, great job Feed.

AdFd's Box;
The logo is Obviously edited, but in an Amazing way,the water drop effect is superb, and really fits with the theme of the box, same goes for the shadow walking away.
The back info, on the other hand, is really low-def and hard to read, in contradiction to Feed's box.The text here is a bit bland, and the background would look alot better if made more visible, again, the mysterious effect caught my eye, but imo, the screenshotborders would look alot better if made , well, mysterious, like the rest of the box.

So,err, well.
My vote goes to:
AllDreamsFalldown

[Feed]

hey guys, have you played this gaem? Its nothing mysterious and special, just plain massacre, really.

[Ayron]

hey guys, have you played this gaem? Its nothing mysterious and special, just plain massacre, really.

Not really, but as said before, we don't know. ADFD's box just attracted me more.

[Feed]

Well, you play as this chick. And that juggernaut-like fag just chases you with that huge maul. You have to hide from him. Also, ghosts help you sometimes - give you potions and stuff. Nothing mysterious, really.

[alldreamsfalldown]

I have Clock Tower 1. It's on my 'Games to Complete' list. i don't think Clock Tower 2 came out in Europe

[Feed]

Can we have more votes? Because i think 3 is not enough to announce the winner and loser, feels quite stupid.

[yummybrains]

im going to go wid FEEDS
i think it has more effort and looks more eye catching

[alldreamsfalldown]

The rules state the voting will be for 24 hours and that was a few days ago.

[dmshaposv]

The rules state the voting will be for 24 hours and that was a few days ago.

Not like the competitons over here actually go according to plan, anyway...

[yummybrains]

The rules state the voting will be for 24 hours and that was a few days ago.

oh sorry it was just feed said about more votes and....
ahh dont worry

[Feed]

I would easily admit that ADFD won if we had at least...8 voices overall. Now we have 3 (or four) and i think its just so damn stupid, lame and poitless to say who won and who lost. Why someone has to lose, if all users are too lazy and cannot vote?

Also, this is the worst competition ever.