LadyKiller Vs. Brettska

[Roboross]

[Brettska99]

I'm screwed in this contest too...

[alldreamsfalldown]

I vote for LadyKiller. love the detail and layout.

[Ayron]

both are pretty nice, good job.
But, i will still have to vote, so;
B99: the first thing i noticed was the tagline on the back, imo, it's oddly placed and too big. overall a nice box, but the back is just average.

Lk:The front is awesome, but really busy, and the text is pretty hard to read. you'll need to pay attention if you want to.
i Really like the effects on this box, especially on the back.


So;
My vote goes to LadyKiller

[Feed]

I'd vote for Ladykiller. Cuz it's more professional, more complicated, more...scary. However i can't say i like it. I think its overdone, you've overblended pictures and now everything looks messed.

B99's box is...well has nothing special in it.

[Ladykiller]

I'd vote for Ladykiller. Cuz it's more professional, more complicated, more...scary. However i can't say i like it. I think its overdone, you've overblended pictures and now everything looks messed.

B99's box is...well has nothing special in it.

neither do I. I don't like how I made it either. I know how atrocious the text on the back as well if not the whole back, but hey it was rushed so.......

hopefully I'll get to remake everything before posting it to the main site, IF I even post it to the main site.......I'm pretty much having a cruddy day right now so idk either. oh yeah, in respect to sportsmanship, I'm voting for Brettska99, I like your box

[Chibi Cloud]

Both are very good. Brettska99's box is great, but the style really doesn't suit me. The back is all right though. Ladykiller's box is superb. I just love the blending effects. I think you overdid it just a bit. The box feels complete. This was a rough match, so good job both of you. I'm voting for Ladykiller.

[ELCrazy]

I think B99 did a superb job on the front, but the back is lacking and too much text.

However, that doesn't mean Ladykiller's one is excellent. It's too stylish and overdone, but he still gets my vote.

[master_general]

i have to say...
LADYKILLER
the layout, detail, and just the way it looks...

[Ervo]

Ladykiller get's my vote. Great design and it just has a creepy feeling.

[dmshaposv]

Brett's box is neatly laid out, but it feels a bit boring.

LK's box is more grotesque, and eye-catching but I don't like the back. I can't make a word out of the text. Which is a pity because looking at the quality of the rest of the box, this could've been so much better.

Still however, I vote for LK's as it definitely catches more of my interest.