Uncharted and Skyrim won't win, they look stupid and gay. And Battlefield looks like a CoD ripoff anyway.
Every Elder Scrolls has had GotY so far so it's the best contender. I think it will either be Portal 2, Skyrim or Batman. Uncharted won't get it and Battlefield and MW3 will get nominated so fans don't get butthurt
I'm currently dying horrible deaths in Dark Souls and loving every minute of it. In between said horrible deaths, I'm also getting some time in on Mass Effect 2 (on PS3) in anticipation of the third installment. I need a perfect save file ready to import.
I have Dark Souls for PS3 sitting on my shelf calling to me and i just may have to give it a go this weekend. That is if i can pull myself away from Gears 3 mp and trying to get the Assistant Onyx Medal. Been playing it since launch. Great game.