The main issue I could see argued is the graphics. Yes I like minecraft, yes I love the old school visual style. But since games have to be compared to the other pc games of the time, I have to expect it to get no more than a 2.0. I know that sounds harsh but it's only fair. Saying that something like this deserves more than that feels simply unfair to other pc games. Compare this to BF3 or Skyrim and it's simply not fair to say some indy group who spent less time on graphics than design deserve more than a 2.0, while the big guys who deliver amazing visuals would be put close to the likes of this? Either way I could see it argued about endlessly.