VGBA Competition: D.S 11 v.s FF 22
. . . . . . .
FF goes on
Last edited by Lodovicok; 03-04-2007 at 09:23 AM.
Diff. between 2
They both are great boxes but the one I choose is FF22. The DS11 just wasn't enough and had no seriousness. FF22 a little grainy... BUT nowhere as near grainy as DS11 .... just an opinion... my vote goes to finalfantaseer22
FFSeer gets my vote....it just looks so official, the colors flow really well, and he has incorporated some great blending.
FF22 for me
FF22 wins this one. That is in-freaking-credible. DS11 is only OK, it's not one of his best.
P.S. Is Wardevil a real game?
yes it is but its also known wardevil: enigma. its an indie game.
Originally Posted by therealslimturtle
"grey bar" LOL
My vote goes to finalfantaseer22. His looks nice and professional and the layout on the back is nice too.
DeathSpawn11 is good, but i dont like the grainy effect on the front and the back is an interesting idea, but isnt executed well enough.
same. Good job FF!
Originally Posted by crazypun88
FOR THE RECORD!: the graininess is apart of the picture. Timmeh made a box using the pic and it had the same look, alls I did was use layer styles to make it look better.
I vote for FF22 DS11's looks kind of empty on the back
I think FinalFantaseer's looks more professional. I don't like DeathSpawn's grainy effect.
I vote for finalfantaseer22, it's presented with a lot more details than Deathspawn's so overall has the big advantage.
I may be the only one, but I really like Deathspawn's.
Now, FinalFantaseer's is amazing. But I see a lot of blending issues. Like towards the bottom of the back, above the ESRB, you can see a straight transition from brown, to red.
Also, the guy on the front, and the guy on the back look very alike, if not identical.
So, my vote goes to Deathspawn.
The colors are great, from blue, to red, to a bit of yellow and brown.
Also, the back is great, in my opinion. I love the setup of the screens. And the information is spot-on.
My vote = Deathspawn. (Like I haven't said it enough, though) =/
the two people on the back and front are the same person duhhh
Originally Posted by Radioactive Bob
hmm i dont see where that brown to red is, but im sure its my monitor or something....
oh boy! i think i won! woohoooooo
good job deathspawn, im actually shocked that i moved on, i really liked your box too
Last edited by finalfantaseer22; 03-03-2007 at 02:33 PM.
Yeah, the red and white are on the back screens.
Anyways, good job FinalFantaseer, good luck in the next rounds.
Congrats, FF22! Well deserved!
I suppose I can now rant about the mistakes on his FFseer's box (whether they've been said befor or not), I didn't do this earlier since I'd look like a prick trying to get people to vote on my box.
1: blending is badly done, the people at the bottom seem very out of place, the info at the back looks like its been cut out of another box and place into this one, the green sopt also looks like its been cut out. you can also see a very faint line that represents where the blue is cut off
2: screens are placed in very odd spots, they're very spaced out and seem out of place.
3: as said befor the people on the front and back are the same, just flipped.
4: colors are the same throughout the whole box, makes it look bland.
5: this doesn't really count but I'm going to say something about it anyway the barcode is blurry
other then these flaws its still a great box, I just feel a need to rant because I feel my box should've had more then 1 vote (thx for the support RB ), plus I'm pissed that I can't find a friggen homing rocket launcher in Crackdown
Last edited by DeathSpawn11; 03-03-2007 at 03:39 PM.
actually its cut out from God of war box >_< it says their in the writing , ok im voting for DeathSpawn11 box . Death Spawn almost explained everything in his post above me so i don't need to explain.
thats what im pissed at too
Originally Posted by DeathSpawn11
thx hunter but FFseer already won the round. thats why I ranted so people (like you ) wouldn't make a vote on me because of all the problems. I lost fair and sqaure.
Originally Posted by Hunter
I found it!
Originally Posted by DeathSpawn11
woops its over ffseer won the round sorry