View Full Version : Round 1: Helghastmist VS. Wickedgamer1
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 09:39 AM
http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/1258/match6jg5.png (http://imageshack.us)
Before Voting Read this: http://www.vgboxart.com/forums/showthread.php?t=716&replies=8
Helghastmist
http://img243.imageshack.us/img243/1731/mistco3.th.jpg (http://img243.imageshack.us/my.php?image=mistco3.jpg)
Wickedgamer1
http://img306.imageshack.us/img306/7420/wicked3qh5.th.jpg (http://img306.imageshack.us/my.php?image=wicked3qh5.jpg)
Ricardo
10-21-2006, 09:57 AM
I really don't know what to say. they are both great boxes. Helghasmist GMV for its cool effects.
Mist 1 - WG1 0
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 10:01 AM
I really don't know what to say. they are both great boxes. Helghasmist GMV for its cool effects.
Mist 1 - WG1 0
Really... no need to keep score, that's my job, cause I Can't vote for anybox (due to that's I'm running the whole thing)
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 10:03 AM
Helghastmist: 1
Wickedgamer1: 0
Fuzzy_duck
10-21-2006, 10:09 AM
Sorry WG1, but I think that HG's tox is not as full. He kept it simple, yet bold. So the score goes to ghast
Ratchetcomand
10-21-2006, 10:14 AM
Easily, the score goes to Wickedgamer1. Hi title is easier to read, with more effects, and the whole box in general looks more Offical .
treesquirrel12
10-21-2006, 10:14 AM
oh snap this is a super close battle well i like the fronts on both of them they both look official but wickeds is a bit better. but the backs are both good too... GRRRRRRRR i hate deciding on these things but i have to go with wickeds cause mists is great and all but i dont like the setup of the back on helghast's box (sorry but it came down too that :( ) so i vote wicked
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 10:15 AM
Helghastmist: 2
Wickedgamer1: 2
triviumfan
10-21-2006, 10:56 AM
WG1 g ets my vote cuz his box is very crips and orignal and helgast is 2 blury on the back an its hard 2 see the screens..but very nice other then that..so my vote gose 2 wickedgamer1
TennisShoes
10-21-2006, 11:01 AM
I vote WG1 I like the back a lot
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 11:08 AM
Helghastmist: 2
Wickedgamer1: 3
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 11:29 AM
I vote WG1 I like the back a lot
better Reason than that. Then it will be accepted.
Ratchetcomand
10-21-2006, 02:11 PM
TennisShoes shouldn't be aloud to vote anymore becusce if he dons't flow the rules then he is spaming.
LnknPrkDude
10-21-2006, 02:49 PM
i vote helghastmist becuase the front AND back are equally well designed (the fronts background gives it a nice effect, along with the official logo and the wii template....and the back is good for the following reasons: the backs template looks cool, and i like how the backs info is laid out)...dont get me wrong, i love both of them, but i have to vote to helghastmist's box :o
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 04:09 PM
Helghastmist: 3
Wickedgamer1: 3
Ghast is who I originally going to vote for because the amount of imagery got my attention, after a bit of thought though; I realized the MS windows stylised background Ghast is using kills the authecticy a bit considering thats a very common windows wallpaper and I feel its not really appropiate.
Wicked gets an extra point for his use of a hand-made template that looks real and his back is more original even if Wicked gamer's front was'nt that original. On Ghast's Robotnik does look a look a little out of place in comparision to the other characters, hes smushed in the corner, and that decreased my enjoyment a tine. I'm not nitpicking out of spite and they're both amazing pieces of work but Wickedgamer1 gets my vote, he got a few more shots.
Let me assure you, General, my intentions were NOT to make the background look like a Windows wallpaper; besides, I didn't even notice the resemblance until you said something. So please, don't accuse me of copying it; it was a coincidence.
So you don't think that my hand-made template looks good? Let me remind you that nobody knows what the back of wii box even looks like. ;)
Radioactive Bob
10-21-2006, 05:38 PM
Sorry Wicked, your is amazing, but Ghast's has that "official" look that makes me want to purchase the game as soon as i look at it. So, while it's very close, i vote for Helghast Mists's box. :o
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 05:39 PM
Helghastmist: 4
Wickedgamer1: 3
Helghastmist: 3
Wickedgamer1: 4
Shouldn't it be 4/4?
WickedGamer1
10-21-2006, 07:04 PM
oh, well you can't re-vote, sorry
:P
no seriously, that took my confidence down to a sliver.
Radioactive Bob
10-21-2006, 07:08 PM
no seriously, that took my confidence down to a sliver.
wow...that's deep...
oh, well you can't re-vote, sorry
:P
no seriously, that took my confidence down to a sliver.
Sarcasm is'nt that? it was just my eyes playing tricks, so no need to lose your self-esteem a notch not that you ever would!!!
All I was saying was which ones I preffered with incorrect names, still I wish you guys told me about an hour and half before hand and to help me avoid embarrisment:p Why can't I re-vote to Ghast?
I'm not simply changing my mind that which would annoy Buell
or Wicked, I'm asking for a reassessment to a typing blunder, thats fair. Sos again:(
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 07:49 PM
i vote for WG1 :D
better Reason.
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 07:55 PM
Ok I'm Confused now...EG who do you vote for?
Ok I'm Confused now...EG who do you vote for?
I vote for HelGhastmist, I preffered the professionalism and I give him extra credit for him putting that template toghether and I had a niggle with the use of a Windows wallpaper on Wicked's, but there both awesome.
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 08:45 PM
ok i look at all the posts twice with EG real vote, so the score is now
Helghastmist: 5
Wickedgamer1: 3
If for some reason someone thinks this is wrong, prove it.
Also Tennis and Wow don't count due to that they have to give an good enough reason for it then "I voted for him"
WickedGamer1
10-21-2006, 09:45 PM
Also Tennis and Wow don't count due to that they have to give an good enough reason for it then "I voted for him"
thanks guys.... :(
thanks guys.... :(
They've securely proven their loyalty to you. lol
Statikcel
10-21-2006, 10:23 PM
Well, what can i say, they are both nicely polished works. Unfotunatly for wickedgamer, helghastmist's is more pleasing to the eye. I like the darker colors better then wickeds pastel look. The only fault i see in mists' boxart is the bottom blue text on the back of the box. The text is almost a pain to read to me, although the top with the 4 pics keep your eyes glued to its awsomeness and more then make up for the lackluster bottom.
Also, i give mist bonus points for making it a WII box, because he had to make the template on the back instead of the standard 360 template.
Helgastmist gets my vote
the reason why i voted on WG1 box cause i liked hes back and front a loot and helghastmist box was eh.... i din't like the back at all i can't see screenshots its tooo bright but i liked WG1 box a loot better so i vote on
WG1 box :D
WickedGamer1
10-22-2006, 12:06 AM
ohh, you know why everyone loves helghast's so much?
he used the same art as the (still tentative) official cover.
lol
even though i'm not aloud to rate, i have to say i really dislike how he layed out the screens on the back. the glare thing he used really detracts from the box as a whole. i mean, you can barely see the screens!
the rest of it really is amazing though, and dont think im trying to influence any votes here, thats just how i feel...
i would honestly pick his over mine.
i should have put more effort into it:(
Maybe Tomorrow
10-22-2006, 12:14 AM
WickedGamer1, because his box is very well put together, and there are no easily spotted flaws.
ohh, you know why everyone loves helghast's so much?
he used the same art as the (still tentative) official cover.
lol
even though i'm not aloud to rate, i have to say i really dislike how he layed out the screens on the back. the glare thing he used really detracts from the box as a whole. i mean, you can barely see the screens!
the rest of it really is amazing though, and dont think im trying to influence any votes here, thats just how i feel...
i would honestly pick his over mine.
i should have put more effort into it:(
According to my box, seeing that the specific art you're talking about had a logo on the bottom right made it practically unusable, so I improvised and took the same Sonic picture and got another Fire background and mixed them together to try and create something very similar.
And I have to be honest with your box too... :) It looks like you just slapped something together. I really dislike the front; mainly due to Eggman just somehow cutting off the ring. You have a talent for blending pictures really well, but for this box it seems the blending was mediocore and random. The text on the back doesn't really relate well with its style. Overall, it looks like something you would see on a fansite. Sorry, just being honest here...
PressCorps
10-22-2006, 02:37 AM
You see what competitions do to people's lives! They're both at each other's throat just to see who's box is better! It's the end of the world as we know it........
TwilightMystics
10-22-2006, 04:05 AM
I vote for WG1 because I like the blending effects, it's also an original cover, because of the background stuff. I also like the box of HelghastMist, the only thing is it's too flashy (I'm sorry thats my opinion,but I like it aswell).
Sergant Johnson
10-22-2006, 06:16 AM
wg1 his box is set up very nicely and is catching to the eye. also it looks almsot like an offical cover.
Timmeh
10-22-2006, 06:39 AM
Arghhhh, There Are Both Sooooo Good, I Had Really Big Trouble Picking The Winner.. But My Vote Goes To WG1.
crazypun88
10-22-2006, 07:16 AM
They are both very very good, but i have to say that my vote goes to helghastmist b/c his is more flawless and the front and back are very well put together. WickedGamer1's box is good, but his front is not as good b/c of the placement of eggman and the girl seems a bit odd and also the fading on the two isnt well done either. So my vote goes to helghastmist.
Fuzzy_duck
10-22-2006, 11:59 AM
Helghast, his seems more uniform in color, and smoothness, (is that even a word?)
PunisherAB
10-22-2006, 01:11 PM
Final Score..good Match...the winner is by who gets te first 7 votes first. So don't get mad because the final score is tie. But it was an close match.
Real Score
Helghastmist: 6
Wickedgamer1: 7
Score after It was final.
Helghastmist:8
Wickedgamer1:8
Wickedgamer1 Wins....Goes to Next Round.
Helghastmist goes to Second Chance Round.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.10 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.