View Full Version : Round 1: The Electric Genral Vs. Triviumfan
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 09:14 AM
http://img324.imageshack.us/img324/7145/matchegct9.png (http://imageshack.us)
Before Voting Read http://www.vgboxart.com/forums/showthread.php?t=716&replies=8
The Electric Genral
http://img302.imageshack.us/img302/352/egjd2.th.jpg (http://img302.imageshack.us/my.php?image=egjd2.jpg)
Triviumfan
http://img322.imageshack.us/img322/8531/triviumfansonicjc5is9.th.jpg (http://img322.imageshack.us/my.php?image=triviumfansonicjc5is9.jpg)
Ratchetcomand
10-21-2006, 10:33 AM
I say Electric genral becusce it has great effects and good info and good images .
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 10:44 AM
The Electric Genral:1
Triviumfan:0
treesquirrel12
10-21-2006, 10:47 AM
well it close but i'd have to say EG cause even though TF had a great idea and good logo. but the back lacks some info and sonic doesn't seem to fit in to well to the dark setting. EG has good colors and a good summary on the back but the only flaw is that the front seems like it needs to be darkened.
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 10:49 AM
The Electric Genral:2
Triviumfan:0
TennisShoes
10-21-2006, 11:04 AM
relly close one but Eg's is better by a little bit
WickedGamer1
10-21-2006, 11:24 AM
as much as i would love to vote for the general, triviumfans box (while clearly lacking in back info) is really nicely designed, and original.
General's box is flawed.
the brightnesses are mixed, most of the text on the back is hard to read, and the screens are massive.
so, i have to give my vote to triviumfan:o
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 11:26 AM
relly close one but Eg's is better by a little bit
Give an good reason, then it's accepted.
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 11:27 AM
The Electric Genral:2
Triviumfan:1
My vote goes to Triviumfan.
His just seems to get it right mixing Sonic and Shadow together, and a lot better positioned rather than General's.
Ratchetcomand
10-21-2006, 01:51 PM
I think TennisShoes shouldn't be aloud to vote anymore becusce if he dons't flow the rules then he is spaming.
PunisherAB
10-21-2006, 01:54 PM
The Electric Genral:2
Triviumfan:2
as much as i would love to vote for the general, triviumfans box (while clearly lacking in back info) is really nicely designed, and original.
General's box is flawed.
the brightnesses are mixed, most of the text on the back is hard to read, and the screens are massive.
so, i have to give my vote to triviumfan:o
You have valuable points and I truthfully respect your honestly. I have no problem, my reasoning for making everything so big is to go with the DS backs where everything is so big and to go with the family friendly image Nintendo normally gives out, for this box anyway.
Timmeh
10-22-2006, 06:41 AM
I Would Go For EG Box, Everything Has Been Put Together Really Well And Triviumfan Back Cover Is Lacking..
crazypun88
10-22-2006, 07:21 AM
this is tuff, b/c i prefer electric general's back a bit more(only problem is the text is hard to read), but i prefer triviumfan's front more. triviumfan's is good and i like the way he created the sonic vs. shadow logo and i like the way sonic and shadow are placed on the front cover. So my vote goes to triviumfan.
Fuzzy_duck
10-22-2006, 11:52 AM
I say triviumfan, I don't like the way that EG's pic spans both sides, it just looks like he put a pic there and added a spine.
hawaiian_dragon
10-22-2006, 11:54 AM
I say EG, both boxes were good, but I love the colors on EG's one and how the back of his box has a really smooth layout and looks more official.
PunisherAB
10-22-2006, 12:59 PM
The Electric Genral:4
Triviumfan:4
Ratchetcomand
10-22-2006, 01:07 PM
I a tie now .
PunisherAB
10-23-2006, 01:48 AM
Since it's an Tie and the time limited is up...I will be the Tie Breaker, due to that how if works it there is an Tie.
Trivium, I like the Idea of Sonic and Shadow together in an game and is nice colors and back.
The Electric General is has an cool style, He has the right Ideas for an Sequel to the Advenutre Series. love the Sonic in the front.
So It an tough one....but I will Choose The Electric Genral for the Win, due to the color and style is close to an real sonic game, but Trivium is good, but too dark for an sonic game.
The Electric Genral:5
Triviumfan:4
The Electric Genral Wins...Goes to Next Round
Trivium Goes to Second Chance Round
WickedGamer1
10-23-2006, 10:58 AM
Since it's an Tie and the time limited is up...I will be the Tie Breaker, due to that how if works it there is an Tie.
Trivium, I like the Idea of Sonic and Shadow together in an game and is nice colors and back.
, He has the right Ideas for an Sequel to the Advenutre Series. love the Sonic in the front.
So It an tough one....but I will Choose The Electric Genral for the Win, due to the color and style is close to an real sonic game, but Trivium is good, but too dark for an sonic game.
The Electric Genral:5
Triviumfan:4
The Electric Genral Wins...Goes to Next Round
Trivium Goes to Second Chance Round
that doesn't sound exactly fair...
it actually sounded biased to me..."The Electric General is Cool"?
seriously dude, i think voting should go on...
not that i dont think the general should have won this round, but you choosing a winner is kinda like a conflict of interest.
PunisherAB
10-23-2006, 11:35 AM
that doesn't sound exactly fair...
it actually sounded biased to me..."The Electric General is Cool"?
seriously dude, i think voting should go on...
not that i dont think the general should have won this round, but you choosing a winner is kinda like a conflict of interest.
then that would be unfair to the rule to the time limited....plus I'm the offical, and can't vote, but I'm the tiebreaker for this situration...like you comment to one of the rules before (for the Tennisshoe issue) I will continue be strict on the rule. Rule are Rules, It they were broken, then it would be an mess.
Also I know what ur saying it, was so wrong of me to sound bias on the EG is cool comment but I meant "EG has an Cool style",I will change it. but by tiebreaker will stand and EG win, due to my other reason.
that doesn't sound exactly fair...
it actually sounded biased to me..."The Electric General is Cool"?
That bolded bit should've been ''the Electric General's is cool'' as in my box, it was probably a typing slip-up, Mr Buell is'nt silly enough to vote me solely becuase of the reason he likes me as an Individual and lets face hes made a few typos before, becuase of hiz animationz .:p
I think you're were getting too assumptive there Wicked.
The person will win by 7 votes by peer or by having the most votes in three days.
Aside that typing slip Mr.Buell was definetely not biased because he said they were both great and said which parts of the boxes satified his tastes, that he preffered the concept and bright colors of mine. It was just a case of preference rather than which was the least flawed and it was fair in this case.
Edit me and him just posted at the same time, youch.
PunisherAB
10-23-2006, 11:39 AM
Wickedgamer...you need to chill down, it's just an touranment for poeple to approve there skills and knowledges, for other to get better, as well as us too. It's not like it the world series or somethng.:rolleyes:
WickedGamer1
10-23-2006, 12:01 PM
Wickedgamer...you need to chill down, it's just an touranment for poeple to approve there skills and knowledges, for other to get better, as well as us too. It's not like it the world series or somethng.:rolleyes:
wow, hey sorry...
just sounded a bit unfair to me, but whatever, mr. official.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.10 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.