Spring Break Brawl: ElCrazy vs. Ervo

[DeathSpawn11]

Banner by Shady

http://i28.tinypic.com/x5cyg8.png

woo! first match of round 1!

Rules of voting:

- Every vote must have a explanation. It cannot be like "I vote for this guy's box because it looks better." Any vote that does not follow this rule will be
ignored until it is changed to fit this rule.

- You may not bash other users' boxes for no reason.

THE BOXES:

ElCrazy

http://img148.imageshack.us/img148/4782/elcrazyboxfl1.th.png (http://img148.imageshack.us/my.php?image=elcrazyboxfl1.png)

Ervo

http://img170.imageshack.us/img170/3761/ervoboxnk2.th.png (http://img170.imageshack.us/my.php?image=ervoboxnk2.png)

CLICK ON THE THUMBNAILS FOR FULL SIZE!!!

The first box to reach 9 votes or has the most votes by 10:00 tomorrow night (Eastern time) will advance onto the next round

ElCrazy: /////
Ervo: ////
THE ROUND IS OVER!
ElCrazy wins!

[xIAMHUNTERx]

Oooh, this is a toughie. They both have their merits, and they're both very, VERY good. But...

Ervo's is fantastic. The coloring and everything really flows nicely. The only thing that is "off" for me is that the logo is a tad to the right, and the embossing on "Wii" on the sleeve is a bit distracting. I also think it would have been nicer if the logo wasn't a "full" logo, but rather something simple: An overlayed Triforce, for instance.

Dan's is amazing as well, and while simple, is very, VERY effective. The monochromatic tone just WORKS. Having the logos tilted and overlayed looks fantastic, like it really is just an outfitting box. But, like many people said on my God of War II box, it would look better with a special edition temp. *breathes deeply* It's a close on, but I'm gonna have to go with

DAN

for the originality factor and the fact that it just draws you IN.

[Shadow the Hedgehog]

Both are great, but I think Ervo's is alittle too busy for a special edition. Its a hard choice, as special editions are always extremely minimilistic or extravagantly busy. But when it comes down to it, I think elcrazy has really captured a perfect special edition box, even editing the template, logos etc.
Vote goes to elcrazy

[Radioactive Bob]

This is extremely close.
I wanted to vote for Ervo, but in the end i felt like i'd seen the same layout on other Twilight Princess boxes, while El Crazy's just looks so unique, and while it doesn't show much besides a wood texture, it's the overlaying logos, the bloody splatter, and all the little effects that really make it look like a Special Edition.

El Crazy gets my vote.

[Dersnap]

This is extremely close.
I wanted to vote for Ervo, but in the end i felt like i'd seen the same layout on other Twilight Princess boxes, while El Crazy's just looks so unique, and while it doesn't show much besides a wood texture, it's the overlaying logos, the bloody splatter, and all the little effects that really make it look like a Special Edition.

El Crazy gets my vote.

Am I alowed to agree? >___>

I agree with everything you said, RB. ELCrazy gets my vote! Sorry Ervo, his just felt more like a Special Edition.

[ELCrazy]

In the spirit of sportsmanship, and also to acknowledge Ervo's hard work, I vote for him, as I feel his box captures the epic feel of LoZ:TP

[Dersnap]

In the spirit of sportsmanship, and also to acknowledge Ervo's hard work, I vote for him, as I feel his box captures the epic feel of LoZ:TP

I thought you were going to comment with something like "I too, vote for ELCrazy's box".

[ELCrazy]

Oh yeah, I'd like to credit shadysaiyan for the awesome temp.

[Ervo]

I hope there's a losers round...:P

[shadysaiyan]

well like some said. Ervo, your is definitly good, but again i just looks like a clone of all the others. different pictures would have been refreshing. EC even though i suspect you threw it together, it does looks pretty good and original and i just like what you've done with it. also is it like a blood splattered flag? also thanks for the credit :D

Edit: i never said who i voted for :D I vote for ELCrazy

[DeathSpawn11]

I hope there's a losers round...:P

I would like to do a loser's round, but with Punisher's comp right around the corner, I want to get the comp over and done with. So, as much as I want to do a loser's round I can't :(

[numerobetically]

ervo... i think. it's so pretty. both are fantastic though. :D

[Airwalker]

I vote for ervo because his box really detailed and he used a lot of colours and elcrazy s box is very plain.. i also like the slip on cover for ervo s box

[milkyoreo27]

I vote ervo because it is more detailed, and looks more like a collector's copy then ElCrazy's

[DeathSpawn11]

oooOOOOooo Ervo's catching up!

about 2 hours left to vote people!