DUEL!!!! Shadow the Hedgehog vs ClonedX

[ClonedX]

Rules:
You must have a reason to vote. If you say "i vote for him because its better" then your vote will be ignored

THE BOXES:


Shadow The Hedgehog

http://i275.photobucket.com/albums/jj283/ClonedX/SHadowbox.png


ClonedX

http://i275.photobucket.com/albums/jj283/ClonedX/ZeldaKartbox.png


Ignored votes:


The first one who gets 8 votes or who gets more votes until Friday wins

ClonedX: /

Shadow The Hedgehog:////

Comments on both boxes here:

http://www.vgboxart.com/view/16479/mario.kart/?replies=11

http://vgboxart.com/view/16470/tony.hawks.downhill.jam/?replies=8

[TwistedTinkerToy]

I vote Shadow the Hedgehog, (Or should I call you Ban Man?) because Clonedx's has choppy cutting, and it's very plain. I also don't like the 2D with 3D.

[Shadow the Hedgehog]

I vote Shadow the Hedgehog, (Or should I call you Ban Man?) because Clonedx's has choppy cutting, and it's very plain. I also don't like the 2D with 3D.
XDDD
I would like to vote for ClonedX for the sake of sportsmanship :)

[ClonedX]

I vote for Shadow the Hedgehog because it has a nice desing,everything is cut out good and i like the glows on text

[Shadow the Hedgehog]

C'mon guys,we need more voters!

[ClonedX]

COME ON guys please vote!

[MARKER]

Firstly... what's with the Outer Glow? UUUEERRGGHHH!! Where's my shades!? lol

Doing DS boxes isn't a good duel preference IMO... there's little to work with in terms of space - probably one reason less people comment (I hardly comment on DS boxes on the main site)

Anyway.... My Vote goes to Shadow the Hedgehog 'cos it looks more like proper retail box. It has the edge over CloneX's because:
1. There's a background on the back instead of just blue.
2. Green on blue is worst than the red glow
3. Screen shots are better because you see all of both of the DS screens
4. and lastly, although the front image of Tony Hawk doesn't match the style of the image on the back, it's better than the non-matching 3D-Kart and sketchy-look characters. Would have been better to use 3D rendered Karts and 3D rendered characters.

[kirby22]

i vote for shadow... his box has the better feel, and Clonedx's is a little plain, and inever really liked cartoons in the real world.. it just looks wierd. Still a good box, Clonedx, keep up the good work.