DVD Comp ROUND 1: VGMaster VS. PunisherAB

[thecodemaster]

http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/banner/banner.jpg
http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/banner/banner-sponsoredby.jpg (http://www.thegraphicologists.com)

************************************

Please, if you're reading this thread - VOTE for your favourite! We need your votes!

RULES FOR VOTING:
1) Every vote must have a explanation. It cannot be like "I vote for this guy's box because it looks better." Any vote that does not follow this rule will be ignored until it is changed to fit this rule.
2) You may not bash other users' boxes for no reason.

The Boxes

VGMaster
http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/round1/jurassicpark-vgm.png

PunisherAB
http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/round1/backtothefuture-ab.png

The user who has SEVEN votes or has the most votes by Wednesday 27th February at 7:00PM GMT, wins this round and will advance!

VGMaster: / / / / - - -
PunisherAB: / / / / - - -

Ignored Votes:
-

VOTE! (and give your reasons for doing so!)

[ELCrazy]

Good one guys!

I'd have to go with PunisherAB. It has a better layout and it fits the movies perfectly.

[kirby22]

i have to vote for VGMaster because it's more clean and fits the movie better. BTW, good box punisher AB

[GuitarMan]

there both so good i can't really choose. i'll flip a coin.......it landed sideways against a wall O.o I'll vote for PunisherAB on this one because i think the front is a little more appealing.

[master_general]

Nice
Punisher Ab get my vote, it looks like a 2 hour project and the style and set-up is nice

Punisher AB

[PunisherAB]

so is anyone else going to vote? :confused:

[thecodemaster]

Bit of a dead thread really, isn't it?

[IceFox]

My vote goes to PunisherAB. His is cleaner and, whilst a bit bland, sort of captures the fun of the films.

[MARKER]

I'll vote for... ermm... not a lot between the two..

VGMaster's has a better looking front IMO.. good big logo, and the raptor was definitely the badass of the trilogy. Not too keen on the glow, but that's minor.
PunisherAB's front is nice, but I don't think the text and images fits too well together. Nicer if the Trilogy was directly under the title instead of in the corner. Also, the main pic is off the first film.. would have been nicer to have a different image or parts of the other films togther.

Back... VGMaster's is pretty good... I like how a small description is put for eadh film plus what's extras you get. Not too keen of the layout.. but okay.
PunisherAB's back I think has better layout.. text isn't hindered by background, and the movie shots are nicely done. Not keen on the basic rundown on text.. especially for a blu-ray box.

Overall... I vote for VGMaster by a hair!

[MugglesMan111]

both are very good, and come very close in the interpretation of the movie, but all in all my vote will go to VGMaster. even though the front pic of his isn't too appealing, the overall layout is just eye-catching.

[Kirbylore]

Vgmaster. I feel like flipping this whole thing around... :D jk but still, I vote for VGM becase AB's front is pretty bland, it sticks out spielburg's and that other guy's names out with weird font, and Im not a huge fan of the back. there are flaws with VGMaster's, but I guess he just has less of them. I would elaborate, but Im typing this on my Wii because my computer got a virus... yeah.... VGMaster gets my vote.

[thecodemaster]

Voting has now ENDED. However, we have a TIE BREAK situation.

Voting has been extended by ONE DAY.

[Sergant Johnson]

im going to have to vote PunisherAB mainly cause his has more style, a sleek design, and allround better layout than the other.

[thecodemaster]

PUNISHERAB WINS this round, and will proceed to compete in ROUND 2.