DVD Comp ROUND 1: Master_General VS. Yummybrains

[thecodemaster]

http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/banner/banner.jpg
http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/banner/banner-sponsoredby.jpg (http://www.thegraphicologists.com)

************************************

Please, if you're reading this thread - VOTE for your favourite! We need your votes!

RULES FOR VOTING:
1) Every vote must have a explanation. It cannot be like "I vote for this guy's box because it looks better." Any vote that does not follow this rule will be ignored until it is changed to fit this rule.
2) You may not bash other users' boxes for no reason.

The Boxes

Master_general
http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/round1/transformers_mg.jpg

Yummybrains
http://www.xyco.co.uk/images/vgba/dvdcomp/round1/transformers-yummy.png

The user who has SEVEN votes or has the most votes by Friday 22nd February at 7:00PM GMT, wins this round and will advance!

Master_general: - - - - - - -
Yummybrains: / / / / / / /

Ignored Votes:
-

YUMMYBRAINS wins this round and will proceed to compete in ROUND 2, leaving Master_General to step down, with dignity, knowing he tried his best.

[VGMaster]

I vote for YB because his front has more action and the back flows nicer

[Ratchetcomand]

I'm sorry but both of these boxarts are really bad. They both have text fonts and all the copy rigth lnfo is wrong.

I'm going to vote for Yummybrains, his back looks a lot better looking then MG box.

[MARKER]

There's not a lot between the two... if I didn't know it... I would have thought it was done by the same person.... template is identical... even the picture of the girl on the back is the same (one is closer-up than the other).

However... I'll have to go for Yummybrains because there's added background to back, and front is a little more adventurous. Also MG's version is suppose to be 2-disc special edition version.. but there's no info on the back that show what's different about it.

[MugglesMan111]

both of the boxes have large similarities to each other but in all, id have to go with yummybrains. reason being, his front is a little more organized and isn't just a wallpaper. also, his logo is more visible.

[Kirbylore]

well, these are both really bad.............. yummybrains gets my vote because it shows a lot more effort. period. there's not really much difference in quality besides the back is a bit better with YB's, so I guess that's it. they are both quite bad to look at...

[yummybrains]

I cannot believe we did the same movie.
Even though i did have a feeling we would.
:p

[Ervo]

Yummybrains box shows more effort and it's a lil better so i'll say yummybrains.

[TwistedTinkerToy]

I'm not crazy about either of the backs, and YB's has choppy cutting, but it looks better, and MG's looks to similar to the official. I vote for Yummybrains.

[yummybrains]

I believe i have won this round.
Master_general was a worthy competetor though.

[thecodemaster]

Congratulations to YUMMYBRAINS, you have won this round of the competition!

[master_general]

i find it funny we made the same movie, but i believe he should have won anyway, nice job :)