WinterFest Round 2: alldreamsfalldown vs. PunisherAB

[Ladykiller]

http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa311/Ladykiller_photo/WinterFest-Banner.gif

One of the matches I'm very excited for. Now it's here :)

NS told me to search for your comp boxes and I found them. Since I haven't received word from either of you yet, whether or not the victor of this match wants to continue is up to him.

Thanks to Koopadasher for the animated banner,

Rules of voting:

- Every vote must have a explanation. It cannot be like "I vote for this guy's box because it looks better." Any vote that does not follow this rule will be ignored until it is changed to fit this rule.

- You may not bash other users' boxes for no reason.

The Boxes

alldreamsfalldown
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa311/Ladykiller_photo/13307_final_fantasy_vii_outer_heave.png

PunisherAB
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa311/Ladykiller_photo/13242_heavenly_wars-v2-orig.png


The user who has eight votes or has the most votes by tomorrow at 7:00 pm est, wins this round and will advance!

alldreamsfalldown:////
PunisherAB:/

This round has officially ended.

alldreamsfalldown prevails and heads into round 3. PunisherAB steps down with dignity.

Ignored votes:

[alldreamsfalldown]

oh cool. Ignore my PM LK :)

PunisherAB?.........poo

[Ladykiller]

haha, a very tight match indeed. They're both great.

Sadly, as much as I want to....I can't vote....being the host yadiyadiyada

(Well, only in an event of a tie that is ;))

[Ayron]

Hmm. this ís pretty tight.
here goes.

punisherAB:


pro's:
-nice blending of pictures
-nice overflowing of the two characters
-good front-poses.

cons:
-a tad ..blue ;)
-screens are stacked into the corner.
-i honestly really don't like the logo,when looked to it in detail, it shows some flaws.
-background behind box is a bit too bright imo.


ADFD:

Pro's:
-great blending
-amazing logo
-pretty good back layout, simple, but effective.
-weird idea, good execution.


cons:
-irregular size of screenshots
-snake is not visible enough, in contradiction to cloud.


So, after thinking some more, and looking over this post

My vote goes to Alldreamsfalldown

[frenchboy1]

alldream's is really coloured and busy. I don't really like the front too. The overall looks a bit odd. Good job then. The only flaw on Punisher's for me, it's the screenshots which looks a bit odd and hard to see.

I vote for :
PunisherAB

[Kirbylore]

so stylish... so sexy..... so... uhh! I vote for AllDreamsFallDown

my reasoning is i absolutely LOVE that design on the front, like I said before its so stylish and original! The back is pretty good, a little too cluttered I guess, but its good.

PunisherAB also had a very good box, it's just that I didn't like the screenshots, and the front seemed a bit too blue, which I think was mentioned before. I also don't like that title on PunisherAB's... it's also touching the sides and looks odd.

but these were both very creative! but yeah, sorry, but ADFD get my vote fur-sure

[frenchboy1]

Seriously guys, you complained when WinterFest was about to be canceled. And now, LK is hosting it, and you don't vote ! If you want WinterFest to still alive, vote !

[MugglesMan111]

both boxes are beautiful and extremely well designed, but im going to have to go with ADFD because i really like the color scheme of his.

[thecodemaster]

I'm going to vote for ADFD. I think both boxes are great but ADFD's caught my eye. It has a great artistic front, and overall feels fitting. I think your logo lets you down, PunisherAB.

[Ladykiller]

This round has officially ended.

alldreamsfalldown prevails and heads into round 3. PunisherAB steps down with dignity.

[kirby22]

this is a hard one. im going to have to choose PunisherAB because a sequel to Heavenly Sword is an amazing idea. Still, Alldreamsfalldown's box is great.

[frenchboy1]

this is a hard one. im going to have to choose PunisherAB because a sequel to Heavenly Sword is an amazing idea. Still, Alldreamsfalldown's box is great.

Why do you always vote after the round ended ?

[kirby22]

it ended? oops, i didn't notice!