WinterFest Round 1: PunisherAB vs. Ervo

[Nerdysimmer]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/WinterFest-Banner.gif
http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/3851/roundonemg7.png
http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/8251/sponsoredbyiq7.png (http://cloudburstpictures.wordpress.com/)
Thanks to Koopadasher for the animated banner,
Thanks to IceFox for the Round 1 banner


Rules of voting:

- Every vote must have a explanation. It cannot be like "I vote for this guy's box because it looks better." Any vote that does not follow this rule will be ignored until it is changed to fit this rule.

- You may not bash other users' boxes for no reason.

The Boxes

PunisherAB
http://img119.imageshack.us/img119/2630/teamamericaqt7.jpg
High Res: http://www.abcrewinc.com/TeamAmerica.png



Ervo
http://i47.photobucket.com/albums/f190/Erv0/sincitycopy.png



The user who has eight votes or has the most votes by tomorrow at 7:00 pm est, wins this round and will advance!

PunisherAB: / / / / / / /
Ervo: / / / / / /

PunisherAB has won round 1 and will advance to the winners' round!
Ervo steps down, and heads toward the losers' round.
Ignored votes:

None

[ELCrazy]

DAMN! Both are really good.

But I'd have to go with PunisherAB, as his is wonderfully designed and fits in with the movie's cheesy adult theme.

[Ayron]

Ok first of all, both boxes are really nice. good job both of you.

Let's put pros and cons against eachother. again.

Ervo

Pros:
-Amazing front
-nicely arranged back
-good effects
-text fits the logo


Cons:
-brightness of characters on front differs a bit
-logo could be a bit grungier.



PunisherAB

Pros:
-nicely arranged back
-beautifull art
-great text arrangement.


Cons:
-Template doesn't look too good.
-outer glow on character on the front looks bad.
-text on front [ ultimate first puppet etc ] is a bit unneeded.
-i don't like how you see someone's back twice.
-the 'you' picture's a bit rough.


overall, my eyes love Ervo's box more.

so, my vote goes to Ervo.

[Ervo]

Cons:
-brightness of characters on front differs a bit


That's on purpose because i wanted that Bruce stands out more ;)


Great job Punisher!


EDIT: My box has Jessica Alba, i can't lose.

[E_G]

I find Evro's box art to be more eye catching, still saying that I think it could do with a longer synopsis. I think PunisherAB's box art is a lot more creative, better made and I don't have any issues with it.

I vote for PunisherAB.

[Ladykiller]

Though PunisherAB is a vet and ervo is not, I think it's seeminly unfair that others keep that distinction and let that drive their votes. Vet or not, it doesn't matter to me as I would vote for the box that I think is superior in terms of overall design.

Ervo's box in my honest opinion is the clear winner here. Yes, I've seen both movies and both boxes capture the feel of the films well respectively, but Ervo's box does more than that I think in that it enhances the original b/w feel of the movie. Not only that, look at both boxes more clearly...

The blending on Punisher's box could be much better and ervo's box wins overall in design and composition and not being too busy. It just looks much more polished and profesional.

My vote goes to Ervo.

[xIAMHUNTERx]

I mean, I don't really "like" either of them that much. Ervo's looks too much like the poster for the movie, and the text on the front of Punisher's kills it for me. But if I had to pick one, my vote goes to PunisherAB, because the back is fantastic and really captures the feel of the movie.

[master_general]

Time to tye it up again!

Ervo

the style of the box is eye popping
the way everything is placed is amazing
it's just amazing

ERVO

[PunisherAB]

Great job Ervo, you did a great job on your box.

Now with my box.:rolleyes:

For all who saids part are unnecessary or cheesy..that's the point as it's a cheesy box off a cheesy action satire. ..and btw this is a satire, so read the description in full view for a laugh. ;)

Good Luck to ya Ervo!

[Ninjamojo27]

I vote AB, his box is overall cheesy (in a good way) and is funny. I dont like Ervo's back but his front is good.
So I go AB

[DeathSpawn11]

my vote goes to AB, his box is extremely loyal to the movie even when being a game. Ervo's box is great to but the screens on the back don't look to great having no border and it looks like they were rushed on their along with the text.

[VGMaster]

I vote ERVO! Because It's got an excellent feel and looks very official!

[jevangod]

I vote for
PunisherAB
his back is put together better

[Moogle]

I vote for Ervo it looks clean crisp; and the text on the back and the backs orginization is great.

[Sergant Johnson]

I vote Punisher, his is overall more appealing. Ervo's is too dark for my taste sorry man I could never see it on a shelf. PUNISHER GETS MY VOTE

[Iron Man]

Sorry Ervo, but I'm gonna have to go with PunisherAB's box on this one.

P.S. Nerdysimmer, remember how E_G told you not to except my votes in this competition? Well, that other account that was made from my IP address is my brother's account, so... yeah...