WinterFest Round 1: Star89er vs. jevangod

[Nerdysimmer]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/WinterFest-Banner.gif
http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/3851/roundonemg7.png
http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/8251/sponsoredbyiq7.png (http://cloudburstpictures.wordpress.com/)
Thanks to Koopadasher for the animated banner,
Thanks to IceFox for the Round 1 banner

Rules of voting:

- Every vote must have a explanation. It cannot be like "I vote for this guy's box because it looks better." Any vote that does not follow this rule will be ignored until it is changed to fit this rule.

- You may not bash other users' boxes for no reason.

The Boxes

Star89er
http://i239.photobucket.com/albums/ff71/star89er/StarWarsBattlefrontIII.png



jevangod
http://i16.tinypic.com/8245ump.png



The user who has eight votes or has the most votes by tomorrow at 7:00 pm est, wins this round and will advance!

Star89er: / / / / / /
jevangod: / / / / / / /

jevangod has won round 1 and will advance onto the next round!
Star89er steps down with dignity, knowing he tried his best.

[Star89er]

I think this one will be a close match. May the best boxartist win.

[xIAMHUNTERx]

From what I can see of jevan's box (it hasn't fully loaded yet XD), it's superior. It has a great color scheme and use of effects. Star89's is good but not great, and frankly, the back kills it. It just doesn't look very professional. In fact... *peers closely* XDDD Is that my template? Yikeos.

Yesh, so anywayz, I'm going with jevan.

[MugglesMan111]

besides the fact that 89ers box isnt a book or film, im going to have to vote for jevangod his has a better layout, and an overall better design, so thats who my vote goes to.

[Nerdysimmer]

besides the fact that 89ers box isnt a book or film, im going to have to vote for jevangod his has a better layout, and an overall better design, so thats who my vote goes to.

Star89er's boxart is based on the movie Star Wars. Star Wars originated as a movie, so therefore, he did not break the rules.

[xIAMHUNTERx]

Yeah, BUT, Star Wars has evolved from just a movie into an entire franchise. Not my call, but... Yeah.

[Star89er]

In fact... *peers closely* XDDD Is that my template? Yikeos.

Actually, it's dmshaposv's temp with the green plastic from Youphoria's temp. Although, it practically looks identical to yours.

[VGMaster]

Well, I'm gonna have to go with my dawg JEVANGOD!!! Sorry Star89er, your's was great, but Jevan's has a great color scheme, excelent blending, and is very official looking!

[TwistedTinkerToy]

I vote for Jevangod because the back has awesome screenshots!

[xIAMHUNTERx]

My favorite part of jevan's box is the EA logo. Those screenshots are from Mass Effect, I believe.

[jevangod]

My favorite part of jevan's box is the EA logo. Those screenshots are from Mass Effect, I believe.

YEa I used one picture from mass effect cause it fitted well with it. I had to make the image lighter though to fit along with the background

[Iron Man]

I truthfully like Star89er's better, I don't really know what it is about it I like, I really like the front.

[E_G]

I prefer Star89er's box art because it utilizes more exciting images. I can identify that the material was restricted but Jevangod's box art has blurry backgrounds, so in the end I find Star89er's box to be more appealing.

I vote for Star89er.

[cheezypoofz]

i think theres somethin weird about jevangod's box but i cant explain what. and star89er's box is just plain awesome. both boxes are really cool but i gotta go with star89er

[Star89er]

So it's 3-4 then? Maybe I'm not doomed...

[jevangod]

So it's 3-4 then? Maybe I'm not doomed...

Yep its going to be close ;)

[Lenny819]

Star89ers box looks a lot better in my opinion even though jevangods looks nice. so i choose star89er

[Star89er]

It's all tied up! Kinda wierd how jevan's box got 4 votes in a row, then mine got 4 in a row.

[frenchboy1]

jevan's is really nice, anyway, the front is a little bit too empty and the text is a little bit weird.

Star's one is nice too, especially the front. But the screens are boring and I don't like the top espace.

My vote goes to jevangod

[Ervo]

I'm voting Star89er. His box is more exciting nad i love Star Wars. I almost voted for jevangod, but i like Star's box more :)

[Star89er]

Now it's tied again! This is gonna be one close match.

[jevangod]

Now it's tied again! This is gonna be one close match.

Yep it sure is. ;)

[Moogle]

Ill break the tie then. And im going to vote for Star, I think his box captures the starwars feel very well. And I think the screens on the back looks nice. So Star

[alldreamsfalldown]

I'm going to tie it again by voting for javengod. They're both fantstic boxes but the excellent style of javengod's box is mucho eye-catching.

[Dancinguy]

My vote is going to Jevangod, although both boxes are extremely good. Sorry Star.

[Dark_Shadow]

I vote for jevangod cuz his box look pretty official and star's one have a bit too much things on it.. sorry Stars:p both were pretty good but I had to make a choice

[jevangod]

So does that mean I win cause it said whoever gets 8 votes first wins and I got 8 and star has 6