WinterFest Round 1: Moogle vs. yummybrains

[Nerdysimmer]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/WinterFest-Banner.gif
http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/3851/roundonemg7.png
http://img235.imageshack.us/img235/8251/sponsoredbyiq7.png (http://cloudburstpictures.wordpress.com/)
Thanks to Koopadasher for the animated banner,
Thanks to IceFox for the Round 1 banner

Rules of voting:

- Every vote must have a explanation. It cannot be like "I vote for this guy's box because it looks better." Any vote that does not follow this rule will be ignored until it is changed to fit this rule.

- You may not bash other users' boxes for no reason.

The Boxes

Moogle
http://i13.photobucket.com/albums/a269/dragonyu/AIR7.png



yummybrains
http://i71.photobucket.com/albums/i151/acdcrocks0174/ymmybrns.png



The user who has eight votes or has the most votes by tomorrow at 7:00 pm est, wins this round and will advance!

Moogle: / / / / / / / /
yummybrains: / / /

Moogle has won round 1 and will advance onto the next round!
Yummybrains steps down with dignity, knowing he tried his best.

[xIAMHUNTERx]

I vote for Moogle... To be honest, neither of them really blow me away, but Moogle's is superior because:

-It looks more professional
-YB's looks kind of slapped together (The random pictures on the front especially)
-The front of Moogle's box is really well done

So yesh.

[TwistedTinkerToy]

I vote for Moogle because like xIAMHUNTERx said, it looks more proffesional.

[Ayron]

hmm.. tough call.
yummybrains:
+original screenshot layout
+nice background
+good text arrangement
-small amount of blending and effects[which i believe defines making boxarts]
-character boxes seem unnessecary.

moogle:
+nice colours
+good arrangement on the front
+colour scheme fits art style.
-bad arrangement for the back
-unnessecary scanlines
-bad text font/size/placement.

overall, after a moment of deep silence.
i vote for Moogle, due to a superior front and colour scheme.

[Iron Man]

I agree with both TTT and HUNTER, Moogle gets my vote. :)

[Justice]

I vote for Moogle, he/she had a color scheme and worked with it, while the text could be better the over all look of it is better than Yummybrain's.

[thecodemaster]

I'm going to vote for yummybrains. The incredible lack of artwork, even for the film, must have made the box insanely difficult to make indeed. For me, it fits well with what I would expect an actual Narnia game box to look like.

Moogle, although I like your box too, I feel that your choice of colours was not very wise and they seem much too bright.

[E_G]

Nerdysimmer please don't accept Iron Man's vote because he shares the same IP as TwistedTinkerToy so it seems untrustworthy.

[Nerdysimmer]

Nerdysimmer please don't accept Iron Man's vote because he shares the same IP as TwistedTinkerToy so it seems untrustworthy.

Thanks E_G. I'll remember that.

[E_G]

Thanks and I like Moogle's box art more because the images flow better.
I vote for Moogle.

[yummybrains]

well, i guess im out.
Oh well...
oh and i just have to say like thecodemaster said there is actually only movie posters for this game.

[frenchboy1]

I vote yummibrains. Why ? What codemaster said...

[TwistedTinkerToy]

Nerdysimmer please don't accept Iron Man's vote because he shares the same IP as TwistedTinkerToy so it seems untrustworthy.

He's my brother

[Nerdysimmer]

As for me, I vote for yummybrains. The scanlines on the front of moogle's boxart killed his boxart. I do like the simplicity of the front of yummybrains' boxart, but the boxed images are unnecessary. The backs of each boxart both haver their downs, but I like the way yummybrains combined the screenshots.

[ELCrazy]

I vote for Moogle as he has a better overall design and color scheme.

[Iron Man]

Nerdysimmer please don't accept Iron Man's vote because he shares the same IP as TwistedTinkerToy so it seems untrustworthy.

Hey, I'll lay this stuff all out.

Iron Man - Me
Sasha Fluff - My sister.
TwistedTinkerToy - My brother's sub account.
Tikicobra - My brothers ex-main.
Infamous Stick - My brother's new main.

As you can see, if anyone should be excluded it should be TTT because he's just my brother's sub-account.

[Ervo]

I'll vote for Moogle. Box looks more professional. Nice work both of you :)

[yummybrains]

i think by counting all the votes moogle has won.
well done dude even though i wouldve liked to go onto another round.

[IceFox]

I vote for Moogle...

Moogle seems to have put signifcant effort into his box and the effects pay of nicely. While they aren't the best boxes in the world, Moogles box seems to just...work better. It's got a better design and effort.

[alldreamsfalldown]

I vote for Moogle. I love the colours and layout though the scan lines kinda ruin it a little. Yummybrains' just looks a bit powerpointy.