Newb Comp. EddieEdwards vs. Master_General

[master_general]

well here it is!!!!

EddieEdwards:
http://img233.imageshack.us/img233/3774/uncharteddrakesfortunecx9.jpg (http://imageshack.us)


Master_General:
http://img142.imageshack.us/img142/511/kdldkxa5.jpg (http://imageshack.us)


VOTE!!!!!!!!!!!
voting ends the 1st

[master_general]

credit to koopa for the AWESOME temp.

[Ladykiller]

both of them are pretty good, but the first box is clearly superior than the second one and might even passed as a vet's box. I vote for EddieEdwards.

[master_general]

tell you the truth
i agree
Eddie, I bet you'll win

[IceFox]

EddieEdwards.

His box is professional, and is very well. It got texture - texture is very important and Master's lacks it.

Also, Eddie...can you tell me where you got that map pic please?

[jevangod]

I vote for Eddie th back is good but the template is messed up and the front is just a screenshot but its still good.

[Nerdysimmer]

Both fronts are pretty good, but the back of EddieEdwards' box is far superior, It could be matched up to some of the vets. I vote for EddieEdwards.

[finalfantaseer22]

i vote for eddieedwards because more effort is show with the leaf, patterns, frames, etc.

[EddieEdwards]

I vote for Eddie th back is good but the template is messed up and the front is just a screenshot but its still good.

how is the template messed up?
plus the front is not a screenshot, in fact its 3 images.
the trees and all in background is one pic, then drake was cut out of another image and added - plus theres the skull blended in.
i also customed the title a bit and of course added the leaves.

not sure where i found the map thats on the back aftyer but it did take a good 2 hours to find it.
the whole idea of the map, photograph type screens on back, leaves was all planned about a week before i even started it.

thanks for all the nice comments

[ELCrazy]

I am very surprised by EddieEdwards' box. It looks professional, and like Ladykiller said, would pass off as a Vet box.

My vote obviously goes to EE.

[TwistedTinkerToy]

I vote for Eddy. Submit it and I'll favorite it! Lol I love it.

[Iron Man]

Oh... my... Edy's box is awesome! I love it! It's better than the official, it's very shmexy. :)

I vote for Edy. :P

[jevangod]

how is the template messed up?
plus the front is not a screenshot, in fact its 3 images.
the trees and all in background is one pic, then drake was cut out of another image and added - plus theres the skull blended in.
i also customed the title a bit and of course added the leaves.

not sure where i found the map thats on the back aftyer but it did take a good 2 hours to find it.
the whole idea of the map, photograph type screens on back, leaves was all planned about a week before i even started it.

thanks for all the nice comments

Didnt mean to say messed up I just mean the corners of the temp is chipped and stuff like small bits are missing but I guess its nothing great job.

[master_general]

Winner is



EDDIEEDAWRDS!!!!!!!!!!!!

Congrats, Thanks all for votes

a new comp might appear soon for new newbs