OctoberFest: Ninjamojo vs. Alldreamsfalldown

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Octoberfestcompetition.png

Ninjamojo27:

Hi-res version found here:
http://i13.tinypic.com/6cg1ifs.png

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Mojobox-2.png


Alldreamsfalldown:

Hi-res version found here:
http://www.vgboxart.com/boxes/PS2/11995_the_lord_of_the_rings_the_return_of_the_king-orig.png

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Dreamsbow.png

Ninjamojo wins, and will head to the Championship match!! Alldreamsfalldown leaves the competition with pride
Ninjamojo27: / / / / / / /
Alldreamsfalldown: / / / . . . .

[Ninjamojo27]

What about Hawpoka?

[KoopaDasher]

Hawpoka has regrettably dropped out of the competition due to lack of a box.

[alldreamsfalldown]

What the hell man??? So I made that second box for nothing?

[IceFox]

Yeah, Koopa, this contest went South. ADFD spent time making one box, then he was forced to make another and now said box is uneeded and this box could be potentially worse than the original - Ninjamojo has the unfair advantage because you let Hawpoka change genres.

ADFD should have the option to get an extra few days to finish his previous box if he thinks it was better.

[Ninjamojo27]

I dont care what you do, but Im keeping this box.

[KoopaDasher]

What the hell man??? So I made that second box for nothing?

I gave you the benefit of the doubt, ADFD. You and I both know this was the better box. I picked the one that I thought had the better chance of winning.

[alldreamsfalldown]

This is the original one. My second one didn't get used.

[alldreamsfalldown]

I gave you the benefit of the doubt, ADFD. You and I both know this was the better box. I picked the one that I thought had the better chance of winning.

Hmmm, well OK I see your point :) I'll post my other box now anyway.

[xIAMHUNTERx]

Despite ADFD's LOTR box being shmexay, I'm gonna have to go with Ninjamojo here, because... Well, just look at it. I mean, wow.

[alldreamsfalldown]

Despite ADFD's LOTR box being shmexay, I'm gonna have to go with Ninjamojo here, because... Well, just look at it. I mean, wow.

Wow is correct :eek: I'm so gonna lose.

[E_G]

Very good job guys however I prefer Ninjamojo's box art because the image quality and color scheme is superior.

I vote for Ninjamojo27.

[Ervo]

i vote ADFD, i just love the theme, EA logo and everything. This was again really hard.

[Ladykiller]

excellent both of them. design, composition, color scheme. but once again, it comes down to quality/detail when I feel like both boxes are very close. I vote for Ninjamojo for better quality and amazing use of color/detail throughout the box.

[ELCrazy]

I applaud both for doing an excellent job, but I'd have to go with ADFD as I really thought he did a great job blending.

[frenchboy1]

Ninja's : A nice one but the front looks a little bit too plain and simple. Also, the logos are too closed on bottom. The screens could have more work.

alldreamsfalldown's : Wondefull job, just a little problem with the screens which are too big and take too much place. The front is just "wow" especially the EA part.


My vote goes to alldreamsfalldown

[KoopaDasher]

I vote for Mojo. His box is just radiates awesomeness. The design is great, the images look great, and I think it is just an overall better box. ADFD's box is nice, especially the EA logo design on the front, I love that, but his back could use some work.

[DeathSpawn11]

I vote for Ninja, his boxes color scheme is really good (....almost too good >_>)
and it's.....just....awesome lol.
ADFD's box is nice to but the EA logo's texture looks odd, I don't like the font used, and the screens take up too much space as Frenchboy1 said.

[Destined Reality]

I vote for #1

Both boxes are good, but #2's back is a little too busy while #1's back has very nice and readable text and pretty good screenshot placement. The overall box has an excellent color scheme too.

[Nerdysimmer]

Great job, both of you.

The front of the Mojo's box looks a bit empty from my stand point, but the back is well organized and easy to look at. The art style is different when you compare the render of the character in the front of the boxart to the background in my opinion.

Alldreams' box has taken the advange because of the front; It is well organized and i see some effort being put on that EA Games logo. The back however, isn't that appealing for me; the background takes my focus away from the text and screenshots. A recommendation from me is to either darken the background, or desaturate it (taking the color away) so i can focus my attention on the text and screens in the back. For some reason, putting a refection and mixing it with the background of a map doesn't really cut it for me, no, It looks good, but it really doesn't fit for some odd reason.

All in all, I vote for Ninjamojo's boxart which is number 1.
Congratulations.

[alldreamsfalldown]

Well done Ninjamojo :) a worthy opponent. Champoionship match?

[yummybrains]

i believe ninjamojo has won

[Ninjamojo27]

Well done Ninjamojo :) a worthy opponent. Champoionship match?

Same to you my friend.

[KoopaDasher]

Champoionship match?

Yes, between Mojo, who won the Regular rounds, and Ervo, who won the SubChamp Finals.