OcotberFest: Alldreams vs. IceFox

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Octoberfestcompetition.png

Alldreamsfalldown:

High-Res version can be found here: http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Alldreamshighdefbox.png

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Alldreamsbox.png


IceFox:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/IceFoxbox.png

Alldreamsfalldown wins this round. He will move on to Round 2 of the competition
First to seven votes wins:
Alldreamsfalldown: / / / / / / .
IceFox: / . . . . . .

[MugglesMan111]

this is extremely hard, but my vote is going to go to alldreamsfalldown


icefox did a great job, very original, but theres just nothing that "wows" me, nice job though
on the other hand, adfd did a great job, feels very official, especially to a very addicting game.

very nice job to both

[xstormthegatesofhellx]

I'm gonna have to agree with MM on this one. Also, I don't like IceFox's template.

The front of the Puzzle Quest is fantastic. I really love the frame it's in. So my vote goes to ADFD.

[KoopaDasher]

In case anyone was wondering, Sergant Johnson was unable to submit a box, as was Roboross, and so I matched their opponents together.

[IceFox]

Ya know, I was this - close to using Puzzle Quest :P

Good luck Alldreams :)

Edit - btw, I am allowed to upload this to the main site now, right?

[KoopaDasher]

Ya know, I was this - close to using Puzzle Quest :P

Good luck Alldreams :)

Edit - btw, I am allowed to upload this to the main site now, right?

Yeah......

[Ratchetcomand]

I love both boxarts but i enjoy Alldreams box because the front looks very official and i like the frames as well.

[werdney]

Both boxes are excellent quality, but my vote goes to Icefox for sheer originality. For some reason, ADFD's seems to generic. While the border is cool and the box is very well put together, I love Icefoxes color scheme and style.

[Ladykiller]

First of all they're both amazing. I can see effort and good design in every aspect of both boxes. As a matter of fact, they both look so good, I don't feel like I can vote without doing justice to the other box. ADFD's box does seem generic sure. Icefox's box is definitely more original design wise. But overall I think it's gonna come down to detail for my vote. I'll have to go for
ADFD for better detail as well as organization.

[VGMaster]

ADFD!!!

It's overall fantastic!!!
It looks realy and has this great feel to it.

[PuzzleMan1337]

ADFD's blows my effing mind :eek:

While good, icefoxes is just lacking in some sort of way.

ADFD Gets my vote.

[ELCrazy]

I'd have to go with IceFox on this one. I love the design, it's beautiful.

[frenchboy1]

I vote IceFox his box looks so cute and colorfull. alldreamsfallow's one looks too "serious" for a Puzzle box.

[thecodemaster]

My vote would have to go to alldreamsfalldown. The game is PuzzleQuest, and I think the box completely suits the title. It is all neatly laid out, as opposed to IceFox's box which seems a little messy, with multiple fonts and bad placement of text.

[IceFox]

My vote would have to go to alldreamsfalldown. The game is PuzzleQuest, and I think the box completely suits the title. It is all neatly laid out, as opposed to IceFox's box which seems a little messy, with multiple fonts and bad placement of text.

My box has the same amount of fonts (3) as ADFDs

[thecodemaster]

My box has the same amount of fonts (3) as ADFDs

I think it's the way that they're used. With your box, the font changes are a lot more noticeable. For example: on the back of your box, IceFox, you have the description and quotes etc. in this tall, suitable font - and then you've got the "Includes music from..." in this completely different font. I think that ADFD has selected more suitable fonts and used them in a slightly more effective way than you have.

Sorry for the bad explanation, please don't hate me!!