OctoberFest: Lenny vs. Frenchboy

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Octoberfestcompetition.png

Lenny819:
http://i54.photobucket.com/albums/g106/lenny819/collection2.jpg

Frenchboy1:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Frenchboybox.png

Frenchboy1 wins this round. He will move on to Round 2 of the competition.
The first one to get 7 votes is the winner:
Lenny819: / . . . . . .
Frenchboy1: / / / / / / /

[shadysaiyan]

Well skill level is obvious here, even though niether one really appeal to me (whats with all the luminus boxes anyway) im gonna vote for frenchboy, his looks much better.

[Destroyer]

The Lenny's one looks done by a beginner and it looks blurry and plain. The f1's isn't perfect and needs more work but it looks mutch better...


My vote goes to frenchboy1

[frenchboy1]

Ahhh finally begun ! Thanks for the votes.


PS : I don't think I'll post it, I don't think this is really nice.

[alldreamsfalldown]

I actually prefer Lenny's. It has that classic N64 look.

[Ervo]

I vote frenchboy's box, it has cool artwork and it's sharper than Lenny's.

[Ayron]

this is hard.
f1's front has a great color scheme, but the monkey faces and pictures above the logo are kind of blurry and squashed.
the back could use a getter colour scheme and lay-out though, and the 'lumines soundtrack' part isn't as right as i hoped it to be.

Lenny's box is really blurry, but has a real n64 effect to it.
plain,but not bland, nice,but not full..

hmm. after alot of troubles, i vote for Frenchboy1, because i loev the retro brush on the front.

[Lenny819]

well the front cover looked a lot better before i shrank it to match the back http://http://s54.photobucket.com/albums/g106/lenny819/?action=view&current=pokemonpuzzleleague.jpg (http://s54.photobucket.com/albums/g106/lenny819/?action=view&current=pokemonpuzzleleague.jpg) yes i am not thet great of a boxartist but it was fun competing :)

[yummybrains]

for me frenchboy's has one it for me

Lenny's: blury, for me its plain as in not much going on

Frenchboy's: Clean, crisp and looks freakin official

[xstormthegatesofhellx]

I like Lenny's, but Frenchboy's just LOOKS nicer and more official. The soundtrack box on the back is a nice touch.

I'm going with FRENCHBOY, because it's fantastic looking and more official than the competition.

[MugglesMan111]

lenny's box seems a little off balance, i mean the template and layout seem....weird. but i like the way the front is set up.


frenchboy has done everything right in his...except for some small flaws, but....


Frenchboy has got my vote

[IceFox]

Well skill level is obvious here, even though niether one really appeal to me (whats with all the luminus boxes anyway) im gonna vote for frenchboy, his looks much better.

If you rated down because of the fact everyone's doing Lumines: don't. There is no way we could have known that EVERYONE would be doing it. If we asked our competition we would have been accused of cheating.

[polar_voado]

My vote goes to frenchboy1

Why? Well, Lenny's Box Is Choppy And Busy, I Think frenchboy1's Box Is Cleaner And Calmer.

[frenchboy1]

Oh ! Thanks everybody : I won ^^ This is the first time I won in a comp. :p I thougt I done a sucking box....

Good job Lenny.