OctoberFest: Mugglesman vs. Ayron

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Octoberfestcompetition.png

Mugglesman111:
http://i215.photobucket.com/albums/cc49/MugglesMan111/octoberfestcompbox-1.png

Ayron:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Ayronbox.png

Ayron wins this round, and will move on to Round 2 of the competition
The first one to get 7 votes is the winner:
Mugglesman11: / / / / . . .
Ayron: / / / / / / /

[Brettska99]

Ayron

+ Very Creative and front looks good, love what you did with the screenshots
- Back seems lacking, needs more to it

MugglesMan111

+ The front looks quite official, i'd belive its real
- Text and screenshots could use a black stroke, box suffers from blurriness

I have made my decision, drum roll please

MugglesMan111 has got my vote!

[IceFox]

My vote goes to...

I like Ayron's box best. It feels nice, bright, clean, crisp, and officia. It looks like some significant effort went into it.

Muggle's looks okay, but the front is a little plain and blurred. Same with the back and looks like a little effort job ultimately.

My vote goes to...Aryon.


Oh and, FIRST!

Edit: Hey, Brett. Can you uhh...STFU! I keed, I keed lol.

[Ratchetcomand]

I vote for Aryon because the front looks very official and fits the game very well. I don't like Muggle's because the back seems lacking.

[E_G]

Mugglesman111's box art is a bit blurry but I feel it's a lot more complete than Ayron's box, because he filled up more space. Sorry Ayron but I prefer his.

I vote for Mugglesman111.

[Moogle]

Ayron because I adore his front for its color and style and the backs unique set up of screens

[VGMaster]

Grr... Hard choice...

I like Mugglesman's because it's back seems more complete.

I like Ayron's because of the front. The back seems a little empty though.

My vote goes to:
KOOPADASHER

Just kidding. I'm gonna have to say:
Mugglesman111

[xstormthegatesofhellx]

Whoof. The fronts on both are great, but the backs just are lacking... Gonna need some time to sit on this one, but I'm leaning towards Mugglesman...

[Lenny819]

i vote for ayron

[Ayron]

i vote for ayron

Explain your vote, or it doesn't count.

Great box muggles, you're a good artist, and i won't be surprised to see you win.

[shadysaiyan]

Im gonna have to go with Ayron, his is more stylish overall and looks well thought out and design. muggles kinda looks like a taxi....that game style is cool though.

[frenchboy1]

The Ayron's one looks empty even though a really nice front. The font doesn't fit very well the back picture.

The Muggle's one looks a little bit empty but it still nice.


My vote goes to Mugglesman111

[ELCrazy]

I'd have to vote for Ayron because I seriously love the front design, even though he could've done more for the back.

[alldreamsfalldown]

I'm going with Ayron. The front layout is gorgous.

[Ervo]

I vote Ayron's box. Front is awsum and it has great design Back could have more stuff but anyways it looks good.

[Ayron]

by the way , the current score is:"

Mugglesman111:4

Ayron:7

at least, that's how my count shows.
Oh and, it's AYRON not ARYON..

[Ayron]

zomg, i actually won?
it's bad to see such a good artist have to leave in the first round.
You were a great competitor Muggles, and i feel honoured to have had to face you.

as for myself,W00T second round :D, thanks for the votes everyone.

[MugglesMan111]

zomg, i actually won?
it's bad to see such a good artist have to leave in the first round.
You were a great competitor Muggles, and i feel honoured to have had to face you.

as for myself,W00T second round :D, thanks for the votes everyone.


wow thanks, and good luck in round 2, ill be votin for ya


and we may meet again someday, possible in nerdy's contest. so...congrats

[Ayron]

wow thanks, and good luck in round 2, ill be votin for ya


and we may meet again someday, possible in nerdy's contest. so...congrats

thanks alot, you are a great and underrated artist,and i'd be honored to face you once more.=]