OctoberFest: Vengeance vs. Ervo

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Octoberfestcompetition.png

Vengeance:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Arcanusbox-2.png


Ervo:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Ervobox.png


Vengeance's box is technically not a puzzle game. He has accepted that he must gain more votes in order to win. First to gain their required number of votes wins:

Since votes are lacking, it will be said that Vengeance wins this round and heads to Round 2 of the
competition.
Vengeance: / / / / / / / / / .
Ervo: / / . . . . .

[xstormthegatesofhellx]

I actually don't really like either of them... The Act Zero box looks too much like the official, and the SPFTRII box looks too much like ELCrazy's. Sorry, guys.

[Radioactive Bob]

Pretty tough to choose, for me.

Vengeance's is very simple. Not plain, but simple. The fire effects are cool, the quality is nice, and the back is nicely organized. Though the front looks a lot like the official's.

Ervo's is actually the opposite in some parts. It's filled to the peak with pictures. And maybe that complexion is based around too simple of a game.
But it is well put together. Although the quality is a bit low in comparison to Vengeance's.

In the end, my vote leans towards Vengeance.

[finalfantaseer22]

i vote for Vengeance because it's well-made and official-looking;

ervo's is way too busy and not very sharp: it's kind of an eyesore...

[Ratchetcomand]

I vote for Vengeance because his back is cool and i like the fire effects.

[IceFox]

I like Ervo's front more than Vengeance's (His looks likes the official w/ brightness cranked down and contrast revved up), but I like Vengeance's back more than I like Ervo's back.

A few minor compliments:

-I like how Vengeance put the Konami logo at the top, it looks perfect.
-I like the retro style on the front of Ervo's box a lot.

And dislikes:
-Vengeance's front is too much like the official
-Ervo's front looks faded in some areas (the ESRB and the temp namely).
-The back of Ervo's looks far too busy and is hard on the eyes.

Also, Bomberman is techically a puzzle game, it's a maze which can be classified as puzzle ("tour puzzle" is the words Wikipedia uses to describe mazes).

I vote for Vengeance because his back is ace. Ervo's front is hawt with an "a-w" but the back is far too busy. Vengeance's is all nice and easy on the eyes.

[E_G]

The front of Ervo's box art is a lot like ELCrazy's box and it's pretty good, but on Vengeance's the color scheme and organization is more professional.

I vote for Vengeance.

[polar_voado]

Vengance's Box Is Not A Pain To Look At, Unlike Ervo's Box, Which Is WAY To Busy.

I Vote For Vengance

[polar_voado]

Vengeance's Box Is Not A Pain To Look At, Unlike Ervo's Box, Which Is WAY To Busy.

I Vote For Vengeance

[ELCrazy]

I vote for Vengeance as it has a better color scheme and it fits the theme of the game perfectly. However, I applaud Ervo for putting effort into a great box.

[Ervo]

I'd like to say that i had the project started before i saw ELCrazy's box so it's pretty much a coincidence that it looks the same. I knew that some one will say something about that. Congrats to you Vengeance, the bitch went down like you said.

[frenchboy1]

Ervo's isn't that clean. It looks too busy and hard to see. Vengeance's one looks cleaner. It's pretty nice.

My vote goes to Vengeance

[Vengeance]

thanks for voting guys, really appreciate this, and a fine job well done Ervo! Your box is great, you did well on it.

[Ayron]

I actually love Ervo's box.
it's unfair that you guys compare it to ELc's box, since they didn't see eachothers box..
I like the effects on both boxes, but the gold-like stripe effect on Ervo's box really took my attention.Plus, i'm a sucker for bright and full boxes, so my vote allthough it doesn't count, goes to Ervo.

[MugglesMan111]

i love both of the boxes truthfully. first off

Vengeance
-amazing blending
-texture
-wonderful back

Ervo
-well executed
-awesome front
-overall amazing

but my vote will have to go to Ervo

[thecodemaster]

Each box has it's own minor flaws, but I'm going to vote for Vengeance as Ervo's seems a little bit too busy/messy for my liking.