Alldreamsfalldown vs. Sockeymeow

[sockeymeow]

http://img407.imageshack.us/img407/5239/rextbannerge3.png

Alldreamsfalldown vs. Sockeymeow

Sockeymeow
http://img184.imageshack.us/img184/6772/kidicarussv1.png

Alldreamsfalldown
http://www.fileden.com/files/2007/8/30/1396002/SuikodenSubmit2.png
First to 7 points
Sockeymeow-
Alldreamsfalldown-

-Note-
All Votes must have a valid reason
not just "it looks cooler"

[finalfantaseer22]

#2 all the way, #1 is so plain and the fanart isn't fit for a box. #2 however has nice colors, textures, composition and overall feel.

[Moogle]

Number 2 for sure. It has nice effects, great textures; number one is a fanart with a logo very plain and not the best fanart to pick for a box (even though its great fanart in itself)

[sockeymeow]

Number 2 for sure. It has nice effects, great textures; number one is a fanart with a logo very plain and not the best fanart to pick for a box (even though its great fanart in itself)

I edited it a lot just cus i dont cut stuff out and render it doesnt mean i didnt edit it...

[Destined Reality]

Wow....first of all, good boxes from the both of you. I think I can see a clear winner in this one though. I vote for #2 because it is very official looking and because #1 looks a tad bit plain. The middle is very sharp, but it gets a bit blurry at the rest of the bg, but nonetheless awesome. I must ask alldreams, how do you get it that hi-res? Photobucket immediately docks mine to a smaller size and I don't know how people can get it to look that good.

Overall, #2 all the way!

[TrevOwnz]

Sorry sockey, i go with number 2 because the effects look more official and he has a border and i can see where he cut out the characters and added some and gave it a background.

[dmshaposv]

Alldreams totally nailed the borders and style of other suikoden boxes.

No.2 gets my vote.

[shadysaiyan]

I vote #2, it looks better overall and i can see the cutting on some of it, so i know a bunch of effort (though it may not be seen) was put into it. it also looks bore official. #1 looks ok, but its just a pic/fan art and kid icarus looks like a girl on there.

[frenchboy1]

I vote alldreamfalldown, there was more effort on it and it looks clean. I like a lot sockey's but it's too simple than alldreamsfalldown's

[alldreamsfalldown]

I must ask alldreams, how do you get it that hi-res? Photobucket immediately docks mine to a smaller size and I don't know how people can get it to look that good.

I made it really hi-res so all the detail would be seen. I used to use photobucket too but stopped for the same reason. Use Fileden it doesn't do that.

P.s Thanks for all your votes :)