DeathSpawn11 Versus Feed Versus Radioactive Bob

[TwilightMystics]

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheVeteranCompetitionof2007Round2Ba.jpg

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheVeteranCompetitionRound2Spinoff.png
Hosted by: TwilightMystics,
Graphic Designer: TwilightMystics , Abcrew © 2006, 2007.

The Veteran Winner/Loser Competition: Round 2

1
http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/Round2DS114tgvfpy2.jpg

2
http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/Round2Feeddirge11vt12.jpg

3
http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/Round2RBre4fullvn12.jpg


VOTES: THE FIRST ARTIST WITH MOST VOTES THE NEXT DAY WINS!

No. 1:|||||||

No. 2:|||||

No. 3:

Due my consideration I've instead of 3 competitors now 4 competitors for the Veteran Competition (Ninjamojo got a second chance, because I had to few people for the planned rounds). So I've decided the two with the most votes may head for The Veteran Winner Competition Round 3: so good luck DS11 and Feed. For Radioactive Bob and NinjaMojo27, they will head on to The Veteran Loser Competition Round 3. Good luck to all and I will begin with the third Round in the weekend.

[yoman44]

N°1 : Just awesome. Nothing to say about it.
N°2 : Great too but I don't like the front. This one looks like a pic on a temp.
N°3 : The front is not bad but I really don't like the logo. The idea is not bad at all too. The back is too plain. Needs more bigger screens. And the frames are ugly.

My vote go to Number1

[like always]

2 of them are awesome but the one that stands out more is the first, it has more effects, and was better edited, N2 although clean is a bit too plain, not that thats something bad, but this time( on the cover it exagerated), and N3 is just Plain horrible.
So my vote goes N1

[Ratchetcomand]

All 3 boxarts are awesome but i vote for #2 because i like the back and the front cover is clean.

[Feed]

I was like...against Mad Spike...? What happened?

[TwilightMystics]

I was like...against Mad Spike...? What happened?

He didn't send me a box in time...:(

[StRiKeR]

I vote for number 2 because I think it's the one who look the most official...:)

[Roboross]

He didn't send me a box in time...:(

I have yet to receive mad spikes box either.. i wonder what he's doing?

Also i vote for box number 2 because the back is so well put to gether that it makes up for anything the front might be laking.

[finalfantaseer22]

i like no 2's back, but i wish he used a different image for the front than the official.
i vote for no 1 because i like the color scheme its organized and the screenshots look cool

EDIT:
wtf? did you switch the boxes around?

i mean to vote for deathspawn's, not feed's

[Feed]

I have yet to receive mad spikes box either.. i wonder what he's doing?
On ICQ he told me that he is awfully busy, but he would try to make something. I guess he didn't magaged to...

[DeathSpawn11]

i like no 1's back, but i wish he used a different image for the front than the official.
i vote for no 2 because i like the color scheme its organized and the screenshots look cool

it's not the official o_O

this is

[Destined Reality]

Wow....just wow! As expected from the veteran's rounds!

#1 Front and back look very official and the font choice is superb!

#2 Front and back look phenomenal, but I don't like the featured collaboration. I think it looks fine as is.

#3 Good front and back, but I think the back is much too simple.

Overall my vote is to #1 because I think it looks very official.

[Hunter]

im gonna vote for DS11 box, his box looks official and very well organized, the back is sweet, the borders are really good and attracting . the text are as it should be on an official box art. but the typo "could be the lat thing you'll ever see..." kinda brings it down a bit since i hate typos.
as for feed's . the front of his box IS the official box art with only a stupid little box telling us that it has a soundtrack annoys the hell out of me! the back is ok i like the borders of the screens but i don't like how he placed Vincent twice on the back. it just makes it cheesy.
and for Bobs box. i really like the front everything is clean and nice but the back kills it for me , the choice of background is bad . ada looks like she is flying in the air due to the background and the borders aren't very attracting. and there is no capcom logo neither on the front nor the back. and there is no slogan on the back. i also hate how he placed the M logo on the right instead of the left, and the nintendo logo is small.

[Feed]

as for feed's . the front of his box IS the official box art with only a stupid little box telling us that it has a soundtrack annoys the hell out of me!
http://media.dirgeofcerberus.net/misc/dc/artwork/artwork26.jpg

Based on this.

[dmshaposv]

Box 1 and 2 are very well made, and make it tricky to decide. Box 3, is well, just not well made - which is surprising since Bob generally makes awesome boxes.


I wish Feed had used a different vincent image than that from the official U.S. box. Looks stylish, but like hunter said, the soundtrack info box could just have been avoided altogether. It's one of those things that spoil official boxarts, and fan-made ones can avoid those and look better. Back cover is stylish, but the screenshot placement could be better. Its these really minor nitpicks that has made me choose Deathspawn's on top of yours.

DS11's box is well organised and made. It doesn't do anything overly creative as say Feed's box, but all the elements are simple and are brought together well. Screenshot frames and choice of font is perfect.

My vote goes to Deathspawn11's box.

[Ervo]

I vote for number two because i like red (:D) and the back in it is f'n cool. Front is cool too. All of them are good. It was hard to choose which one to vote.

[Ninjamojo27]

#1-His box looks as if it is official and it ahs a great design
#2-Good color scheme but that front box thing is distracting. Plus the ESRB is huge.
#3-The front is awesome but the back kills it.

I vote for #1

[finalfantaseer22]

it's not the official o_O

this is

no he like... switched the boxes around....
what i said about no 1 i mean about no 2 and vice versa...
maybe i just didn't see right the first time...

anywho, i edited my post, i vote for deathspawn

[IceFox]

All are good, though my vote goes with NUMBER ONE.

I like this one. The scheme is nice and the images are all high quality - it looks official. The screenshot borders are well designed and DS used a good choice of fonts.

Feed's is good too. The front looks official - probably because it is (not saying it was Feed's intent, it obviously was not, but using the official front can kill a box): LINK (http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/1/11/Dirgeofcerberususbox.jpg)

I like the layout and design of the back, but again, the front ruins it for me (it's well designed but it's pretty much the official)

RadioactiveBob's box is also pretty good. I like the idea of it though the screenshot layout is bad as is the background used for the back. The front is pretty good but the back isn't

[Dark_Shadow]

They are all three fantstic but #2 is my favorite because it really look official and has the FF feeling :)