Round 1: Ayron versus Dark Shadow

[TwilightMystics]

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheNewbeeCompetitionof2007Banner.jpg

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheNewbeeCompetitionRound1.png
Hosted by: TwilightMystics,
Graphic Designer: TwilightMystics , Abcrew © 2006, 2007.

1
http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/Ayron_001.jpg

2
http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/Dark_ShadowRound1boxart.jpg

VOTES: THE ARTIST WITH THE MOST VOTES THE NEXT DAY!

No. 1:||||

No. 2:|||

Ayron wins this Round, and heads to The Newbee Winner Competition: Round 2.
Dark_Shadow loses , and heads to The Newbee Loser Competition: Round 2.

[alldreamsfalldown]

Oooh tough one. I'll have to go with #1. Sharper and more attention to detail.

[Ratchetcomand]

I going to vote for #2 because the detail is cool and the front looks nice.

[dmshaposv]

Box # 2: I'd wish the maker had used the official killzone 2 logo than that user-created one. The blue colored "2" looks cheesy. The logo placement is kinda rough and the spine's color looks out-of-place. The back is also a bit underwhelming. Good effort, though.


I am pleasantly surprised by the first box. Excellent job Ayron, you've definitely got the sweet spot of the font, text color and organisation. Probably your most impressive box to date.

Easily the first box gets my vote as it is better organised, very easy on the eyes and looks crisp.

[Ayron]

First of all, thanks dms and adfd.:P
and good luck Dark_shadow ^^
great box btw.=D, this is going to be a close call!

[StRiKeR]

Hummm.. both are very nice
but I must go for the second one because I like all the details in it and the front is very cool:)

[Feed]

I vote for number 2

It has awesome front and well presented back.

Number 1 seems a bit too simple to me, don't like it.

[Darthspazz]

I dont care for the killzone logo or the font/text.

BOX #1!

[Chibi Cloud]

Box #1. It's more clean and simple. It also packs a lot of detail. Box #2 really didn't make it for me, the logo on the spine is placed incorrectly. It doesn't really have that catching feeling. It's sorta boring. :/
My vote goes to Ayron.

[Ayron]

Darth, you have to explain your vote xD
damn, this is a close match.

[yoman44]

I vote #1 because because the front and the back fit well together. And I really looove the front. So my vote go to #1

[Ayron]

this round has ended,right?
it's a day after submission.

[Hajimaru]

Well i still wanna vote though
I vote for ayron because i think his front is more clear and way more nicer then the front of dark shadow (no offense)
although i prefer the back of darkshadow but i also like ayrons back so overall ayron scores more points in my opinion both boxes where nice though

[Ervo]

I dunno if voting has ended but i still vote. My vote goes to number one. It looks better because number two's logo is a little bad and the font deosn't fit. Great job guys!