Round 1: E_G Versus DeathSpawn11

[TwilightMystics]

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheVeteranCompetitionof2007Banner.jpg

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheVeteranCompetitionRound1Tributet.png
Hosted by: TwilightMystics,
Graphic Designer: TwilightMystics , Abcrew © 2006, 2007.

1
http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/E_GRound1box.jpg
2
http://i15.tinypic.com/4t764bs.png[/

VOTES: THE FIRST WITH THE MOST VOTES THE NEXT DAY WINS

No. 1:||||||

No. 2:|||||

E_G wins this round and heads to the next round: The Veteran Winner Competition: Round 2.
DeathSpawn almost won and Loses this Round and heads to the next round: The Veteran Loser Competition: Round 2.

[Roboross]

I vote for E_G because the cover is put together well and it draws you in more than the Perfect Dark Zero Box. Also the back looks like he had put more thought in positioning everything. Though i do like deathspawns screenshot borders, but all together the Heavenly Sword box personally looks better to me.
I vote for #1

[alldreamsfalldown]

Hmmmm close one but I vote for #2

It's very striking and it grabbed my attention immediatly.

[Ayron]

ohh, again, very good work both of you.

first box is REALLY nice, nothing really to say about it,
but the second box, the head on the front is another style than the one on the back,which annoys me.
so i'll have to go with number 1!

[Nerdysimmer]

Holy.... They're both really good....:eek:
Both of them have really put a lot of effort in both of these boxarts. :)

1 has really done a very good job in the back, the text is neatly organized, and there's a lot of it. It also caught my eye really quickly. 2 has neatly organized text, and great images as well. However, i see a graphical blemish on the back M logo.

You both did a very good job on these, but my vote goes to:

#1

[lutherjw]

I like the design of both, and the screenshots on number two are awesome, but number one looks cleaner and more official.

I vote for #1.

[DeathSpawn11]

lol, is there going to be a loser round?

[dmshaposv]

I'd say box #1.

I think E_G got the colors right, Deathspawn's original was too intense. Also the text placement, choice of font, are all better in E_G's remake of DS's box.

The perfect dark box is nice update from E-G's orginial version. Deathspawn's version is sharper and more crisp...however I don't particularly like the screenshot border and choice of font.

On the whole E_G's box is a bigger improvement of Deathspawn's box than vice versa.

[TwilightMystics]

lol, is there going to be a loser round?

yes, don't worry!

[Destined Reality]

Overall, both the boxes are great! Both the fronts are amazing. It took me quite a long time to decide because both the backs are also amazing, but I think I go for #1 because the text and font look very proffesional. #2's text size isn't as consistent, but the rest looks very good.

Anyway, my final vote is for #1.

[Ninjamojo27]

My vote is for #2. The colors are all bold and and great mixing. The front of #2 to me looks ameatur for his skill level.

[Feed]

For me its number 2. I really like how its made, the improvements are really good and nice. Very eye-catching.

Number one is good and really proffesionally done, but really, feels like something is missing.

[Ervo]

I vote for #2, i like it more. It grabbed my attention immediatly. Heavenly Sword box is awesome too. Tough competition.