Round 1: Moogle Versus BlazeTK

[TwilightMystics]

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheNewbeeCompetitionof2007Banner.jpg

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/TheNewbeeCompetitionRound1.png
Hosted by: TwilightMystics,
Graphic Designer: TwilightMystics , Abcrew © 2006, 2007.


1

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/MoogleRound1boxart.jpg


2

http://i97.photobucket.com/albums/l215/His_Dark_Materials/BlazeTKRound1.png

VOTES: THE FIRST WITH EIGHT VOTES WINS

No. 1:||||||||

No. 2:||||||

Moogle enters the Winner competition of the Newbee Competition of 2007, unfortunally BlazeTK loses but have a second change in the Loser Round of the Newbee Competition of 2007. Thanks for voting and good luck for the next Round(s).

[alldreamsfalldown]

Why does this have the vet title bar?

[E_G]

I prefer the first one because of the colors, but the back isn't very realistically organized, and it's missing company logos. On the second one I get this feeling it's too plain even for a RR box, and I don't like the picture on the front because it looks like a photograph.

I vote for box No. 1.

[Nerdysimmer]

you used the wrong banners!

Anyway, #1 has some good coloring going on, and also his back seems more complete because of the background. However, #2 has little life in the back, and the front looks like an old photo...

I vote for #1

[Mad Spike]

White text on the yellow background, screenshots without borders - it's the things I don't like in the first box. It make it looks vey plain =(
The colors on the front and back of the seconf box doesn't mach, but box looks more detailed. There are some different text colors and style, effects, developers logos and so on. But I should agree. The front cover art looks like photo, and it's too sharpen :P
I vote for #2...

[dmshaposv]

I like the colors and the use of text in the first one. If only there was some border around the screens of the first one and a light 1px stroke around the text (in black color) I'd be even better.

I don't particularly like the effects on the second box, even though it is much better organised than the first one. The purple border around the screens looks out of place and the font somehow doesn't seem to feel right.

Overall I'd say box #1, but only by a very slight margin.

[LoveKuja]

I choose Ridge Racer. Genji box misses quite a few important logos. Also the back cover just really doesn't tell anything about the game, and the placings are quite unimaginative.

Vote for #2.

[BlazeTK]

Just asking, wasn't my match against Roboross?

[Roboross]

Just asking, wasn't my match against Roboross?

Yeah, but i guess since i dropped out and then Twilight let me re-enter he set me in the 3-way match.

Also i like Ridge Racer better because of the blue-ish look and also i think the back is put together better.
Vote for #2

[Ervo]

Box number one looks a little better. So my vote goes to first one.

[ashlypop]

1st box, bcuz the box has a nice color scheme and the back text matches the box aswell

[like always]

I Vote The Rigde Racer One, Because Although I Dont Like Either, Well The Back Of N1 Is Horrible, And N2 Is Good, Not Great But Good.
So My Vote Is N2

[Ayron]

Ok..
number 1:
logo bothers me, don't ask why.
esrb wrong shape and placed in the corner
on the back;no borders and bad text.


Number 2:
front:overdid the sharpening a bit.
Back:borders a bit too big and the bar on the[ just under the template ] could've been done better..


i still have to go with Nr.2!

[IceFox]

Both are decent. The front's on both aren't very good (no 1 is very blurry, no 2 uses a basic filter), so the back's are where I have to judge, and I vote for Number 2

The back for number 2 is cleaner and layed out much nicer and has a clean look to it, like the other boxes for the game.

[alldreamsfalldown]

Number 1

The colours are more vibrant and the back is a lot more detailed.

[2cool2spy]

woah, #1 is my vote!

my reason: it seams more like what a real boxart should be. the other one just looks to bland for it to be a boxart

[Mad Spike]

Number One - 7 Votes
Number Two - 6 Votes

[Chibi_Chi_Chan]

I vote for number 1

It's colours are more vibrate and catch my eyes better than number two. Number two is too blah.

[alldreamsfalldown]

8 - 6

Moogle Wins!!

[TwilightMystics]

8 - 6

Moogle Wins!!

No Ervo hasn't explained why he voted on no.1!

[susuwatari]

Box number one is a lot more interesting and seems to have more effects so i vote Moogle. Number 1

[Feed]

Well, number 2.

Because of better organisation, colors and design. Number one is kinda empty on the back, that really makes it worse than number 2.

My vote for number 2

[NeRd]

Box number one plz because...I just like it better.

[BlazeTK]

I think I lost because counting up it should be about 8 valid votes for Moogle :( But well done dude and I hope you do well on your next round.

Also here's my view on your box: the backgrounds are nice and passionate but it lacks the things to complete it. The back is too empty (needs more descriptions, information, etc.) and pictures need borders. Also the front and back both need dev logos. The guy on front is also kind of blurry.

Try to improve on your next box mate and keep it up :)

[Moogle]

I think I lost because counting up it should be about 8 valid votes for Moogle :( But well done dude and I hope you do well on your next round.

Also here's my view on your box: the backgrounds are nice and passionate but it lacks the things to complete it. The back is too empty (needs more descriptions, information, etc.) and pictures need borders. Also the front and back both need dev logos. The guy on front is also kind of blurry.

Try to improve on your next box mate and keep it up :)


Thankies Blaze, your box was great too ^^ it was nice and clean, the back was great. But thanks for the congrats and ill promise to imrpove on my next box.

[like always]

i cant vote anymore, cause i already did, but i can persuade others to vote on number 2!!!! because... the back is way better on number 2!!!!! just compare, its just better, i dont wanna see a good box, like the n2, lose to the not so good box ( no offense). you guys will see im right.

[Roboross]

Soo.. Did Moogle win or not?

[Mad Spike]

Yes, he did :)

[Ervo]

Congrats for the winner!

[BlazeTK]

i cant vote anymore, cause i already did, but i can persuade others to vote on number 2!!!! because... the back is way better on number 2!!!!! just compare, its just better, i dont wanna see a good box, like the n2, lose to the not so good box ( no offense). you guys will see im right.

Thanks for your support on my box but the competition is already over and I lost lol. Too bad eh? :(

[Roboross]

Yes, he did :)

Alright i was just wondering because people kept voting and Twilight never put it down that he did.