View Full Version : Ol' School: E_G v Lodovicok
07-09-2007, 02:54 PM
First to 5 wins. Round ends 11th July.
07-09-2007, 03:30 PM
Very close call on this one.
I think Lodovicok's box has a very official and epic feel to it. But just small design decisions kinda break that feel. Particular the text throughout the box - the synopsis at the back, the title in front could've been made a bit bigger with a better choice and color of font.
E_G's box is so stunning and colorful - I'm rather shocked why it isn't in the hall of fame. It looks perfect in almost every way - except I would make the background in the back cover a little lighter or faded.
My vote goes to E_G.
07-09-2007, 04:26 PM
usually i immediately love EG's art over most, but lodo did pick one of my favorite boxes from him...
its a toughy for me, but overall i think EG's is so colorful and very official looking, plus it is one of my favorites on the site.
however, i just recently saw that the art EG used on his front was actually also used on the official box (he may or may not have been aware of this...) so... i'm voting for
Lodovicok because that is one of his best works (not to mention i forgot about it). the box has style---i just love the effects on the front and the images used.
however, i just recently saw that the art EG used on his front was actually also used on the official box (he may or may not have been aware of this...) so... i'm
Well you use art on a lot of your boxes that are featured on official boxes, so you're guilty too. :p I know I used artwork on mine, that a bit of is used on the back of the official box, but to be honest I don't particularly care and I don't know why you would.
07-10-2007, 02:01 AM
omg, i'm happy to be a new schooler. o.o'
anyways, both boxes look great, and imo the fronts are equally good, so i;m going to have to vote according to the back..
E_G's back looks great, and i love the arrangement, where as Lodo's screenshot arrangement doesn't look as good as E_G's
my vote goes to E_G
07-10-2007, 04:35 AM
I prefer E_G box but the Lodovicok looks good too, but too pale for me.
I vote E_G
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.10 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.