VGBA Summer Contest: PunisherAB Versus TwilightMystics

[E_G]

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/shadysaiyan/VgbaSummerCompBanner.jpg

PunisherAB
http://img340.imageshack.us/img340/8800/sonicretroremixpab2vx6vk0.jpg
High-resolution link (http://fc01.deviantart.com/fs17/f/2007/164/4/c/Sonic_Retro_Remix_by_PunisherAB.jpg)

TwilightMystics
http://img529.imageshack.us/img529/6595/sonic2boxartminiwv1md6.png
High-resolution link (http://img480.imageshack.us/my.php?image=sonicthehedgehog2boxartsm7.jpg)

The person with the first six votes wins. You must have a good reason behind your vote.

Please vote for your favorite box by posting.
PunisherAB 0 TwilightMystics 6
TwilightMystics wins his round, but PunisherAB leaves the competition with pride.

[lord_arcanus]

I have to vote for TM here. His box just blows me away. Punisher's is very nice but those effects don't really "wow" me. Also the text on his box isn't very readable. Twilight's box is absolutely flawless.

I vote for TwilightMystics

[PunisherAB]

Punisher's is very nice but those effects don't really "wow" me. Also the text on his box isn't very readable.

it's readable, you have to look at the Hi-res version of it.

[lord_arcanus]

it's readable, you have to look at the Hi-res version of it.

oh, i see it now, but still, i do prefer twilight's.

sorry.

[E_G]

PunisherAB's box made me go "very nice". TwilightMystics' box made me go "Wow!". TwilightMystics' box looks detailed, futuristic and very epic.
I vote for TwilightMystics.

[PunisherAB]

oh, i see it now, but still, i do prefer twilight's.

sorry.

That's ok, atleast you can read it.:D

[werdney]

This is really close. I like the sketch or whatever effects on AB's, but TM's just looks so much more professional. I love the front. My vote goes to TwilightMystics.

[Ayron]

these are great boxes! mine doesn't even match the greatness of them.
i vote for twilightmystic, since i just love the front.

[lord_arcanus]

hey Twilight, can i have your logo sometime? You know me, the sonic fanboy. :D

[CruSadEr]

lol "Sonic's going retro in this remix", other than that cheesy thing Punisher's is okay (great), but, TwilightMystics's is the one that really catches my eye. SO I vote
TwilightMystics

[TwilightMystics]

hey Twilight, can i have your logo sometime? You know me, the sonic fanboy. :D

You can, PM me then. BTW I worked my ass of with this box!

[finalfantaseer22]

i'm sorry, but i just really do not like punisher's...
the colors are strange the composition is off, the logo isn't very nice... where as icarus's is vibrant, has an interesting design with a well-organized back cover, and over all it looks quite official.
twilightmystics all the way.

[E_G]

Thanks for voting. Good luck PunisherAB, for if you enter the next competition.

[Ayron]

"but leaves the competition with pride"
lol im gonna hear that too =]
punisher did his utmost, but coul'n't reach twilight's box..
great box both of you!