VGBA Summer Contest: E_G versus PunisherAB

[E_G]

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/shadysaiyan/VgbaSummerCompBanner.jpg
E_G
http://img408.imageshack.us/img408/6217/killingdayny9.jpg (http://imageshack.us)
PunisherAB
http://img247.imageshack.us/img247/4360/abgoldeneyereloadedon9lj4.png

The person with the first six votes wins. You must have a good reason behind your vote.

Please vote for your favorite by posting.
E_G 6 PunisherAB 2
E_G wins but PunisherAB loses with dignity.

[Ratchetcomand]

I like PunisherAB box because it has a great feel to the James Bonds movies and i love the style of the box as well .

[Feed]

I vote for E G

[Timmeh]

I vote for E G

You need a better reason.

I really like both boxes but I prefer E_G's box art because I like the simplicity of the box it looks nice and clean.

[shadysaiyan]

Well, Punishers box is nasty to me, looks choppy/rushed. EG's looks nice and tough it does look like there was no editing to the pic, maybe some desaturation though., but it loks nice.

I vote for E_G

[IceFox]

Punisher's looks choppy and unifnished. Even if that was the point, it still didn't come out well. E.G.'s on the other hand, looks smoother and cleaner and placed right. No choppiness and it looks very complete.

So, my vote goes to E.G.

[E_G]

EG's looks nice and tough it does look like there was no editing to the pic, maybe some desaturation though., but it loks nice.

I vote for E_G
I faded the Helghast army into the flag, flipped things around and edited the colors so the fade would work. I admit there wasn't a lot of effort but it didn't require it.

[shadysaiyan]

atleast it came out good :D

[finalfantaseer22]

although i don't like how EG's image contrast doesn't match the logo and it seems quite hazy, i absolutely hate the sketched gadgets in the center of AB's... it just doesn't fit at all to me. the idea is nice, but the quality is kind of grainy and i don't like all of the white.

EG

[Feed]

You need a better reason.

I really like both boxes but I prefer E_G's box art because I like the simplicity of the box it looks nice and clean.

Well, i must admit EG's box is a bit too bright and unfinished. But Punisher's box looks quite crappy, sysly. The gun in the centre, that digusting canvas filter - no. That is no good. But from what we have i pick EG's box.

[Themanslayer009]

i vote eg becuase i like how the flag is nice and blended into the wall kinda and its better than original

[Chibi Cloud]

I vote for AB, cause his is more simple. EG's is too bright sorta. The NTSC U/C is high. That's just a minor flaw, not that big of a deal really. AB's box looks like more effort was put in to it.

Punisher AB

[E_G]

Thanks for voting.