Feed vs. E_G

[Feed]

Feed:
http://img176.imageshack.us/img176/208/fanikc1.jpg

E G:
http://img179.imageshack.us/img179/3016/anniversraykp8.jpg




First one to get 10 votes wins.

[CruSadEr]

This is very hard to choose. I like EG's front better, but I like the fact the Feed added a back. EG's logo is also much better, and I don't like the fact that the bar code on the back of Feed's art is transparent. I think that the description of each game is corny also. But pointing out the negatives won't help. But I like the concept of what Feed is trying to portray. He placed the games very nicely, and if EgG had a back, this would be much easier to compare. Feed's just looks much more official. I vote FEED

[TrevOwnz]

i like E_G's more. nice job both of you.

[Feed]

This is very hard to choose. I like EG's front better, but I like the fact the Feed added a back. EG's logo is also much better, and I don't like the fact that the bar code on the back of Feed's art is transparent. I think that the description of each game is corny also. But pointing out the negatives won't help. But I like the concept of what Feed is trying to tell. I am going to have to vote..........
FEED

Its official logo, man. Can't fo anything about it.

[Mad Spike]

Feed's Box is more similar on collectors edition. It is looked very stylishly.
E.G.'s Box is excelent too, I like form of a framework. But absence of a back cover does it not competitive on 100%.
My vote is for Feed.
P.S. Boxes are cery cool.

[CruSadEr]

Its official logo, man. Can't fo anything about it.

You mean there is actually an Anniversary Edition coming out?

[E_G]

Its official logo, man. Can't fo anything about it.
Well I did say it had to be called "Final Fantasy Anniversary Collection" when I challenged you. I would've used the logo you used otherwise, although I'm not too bothered so let's carry on.

[Feed]

You mean there is actually an Anniversary Edition coming out?

http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Final_Fantasy_20th_Anniversary


Well I did say it had to be called "Final Fantasy Anniversary Collection" when I challenged you. I would've used the logo you used otherwise, although I'm not too bothered so let's carry on.

Well, technically, it is a collection. Compilation, actually. Consists of 4 games.

[Chibi Cloud]

Oh God. Their both so good! Man! This is tough! Feed, your box is huge! EG, I love the sweet effects! It's good, and I don't know what to say. How you added Squall, Tidus, and Cloud. Just everythings good about it. If I had to give it a rating, it would be a 5. Sorry Feed, yours is excellent too! EG gets my vote. Good job both of you. Pat yourselfs on the back.

[Feed]

Wow, just wow...Ive lost.

Thats kinda unfair...I see a lot of voices, but no comments at all. Lets make it this way: I count only voices that are followed by a comment. IMO, the best way.

With taht rule i have 2 voices and E G has 3.

[Feed]

And yea, i am quite pissed, and i think taht i don't want to be a part of a community that is unfair. People vote against someone just because the person, who made that box, is not populat on forum, he's new, a newbie. This is not right. If this stuff keeps happening, then i would not like to continue coming here every day.
Everytime I submit my boxes i get 5/5 pionts, great feedback, perfect marks and stuff, but during the comps i get negative feedback and stuff. I dont like it. Its unfair.


BTW guys, when i first sent my box to EG he said that my box is great, that it would win. But now i am soo pissed that i might not want to compete in the summer competition. Because i know it would be unfair. I know that i would lose in the first round no matter how good my box is.

Thank you and good bye, cheaters. And btw, Chibi Cloud, my box is not huge, its high resolution. The bigger the pic, the better the quality. Remember this, boy.



I am sure that almost half of you can't tell me who is in the centre or in the lower lets corner of EGs box.

[Mad Spike]

And yea, i am quite pissed, and i think taht i don't want to be a part of a community that is unfair. People vote against someone just because the person, who made that box, is not populat on forum, he's new, a newbie. This is not right. If this stuff keeps happening, then i would not like to continue coming here every day.
Everytime I submit my boxes i get 5/5 pionts, great feedback, perfect marks and stuff, but during the comps i get negative feedback and stuff. I dont like it. Its unfair.
BTW guys, when i first sent my box to EG he said that my box is great, that it would win. But now i am soo pissed that i might not want to compete in the summer competition. Because i know it would be unfair. I know that i would lose in the first round no matter how good my box is.
Thank you and good bye, cheaters.
Dude, Everything will be ok. You will win ;) Well, you know... shit happens...
You are too good to leave the comunity. And cheating its a regular stuff no matter were, who, when and why.

[Feed]

Dude, Everything will be ok. You will win ;) Well, you know... shit happens...
You are too good to leave the comunity. And cheating its a regular stuff no matter were, who, when and why.

This is soo fkn childish. First they say you're the best, then they complain about the barcode being transparent. LAME! CRAP!

I just hate people who think they are soo damn good, who think the are pros, but when it comes to making something - they hide. They complain about the site being flooded by noobs, but THEY are the noobs who destroy the site. Cmon guys! Any of you, make a box that is better than mine! I DARE YOU! >:(((((

I would not be surprised if my box would fail against Arcanus. Now i know how people vote here. The look for every tiny little detail that doesn't even matter at all and say that it ruins everything, makes your box awful.

[E_G]

Excuse me, I should've told you not to make a poll to prevent people voting for the author, not their submission and without a reason.

There's a reason polls aren't used in the actual Summer Competition. Just keep participating in the Summer Competition please. Remember people can't vote there without a good reason and the use of a poll.

Don't get pissed Feed. I admit yours is better, I even voted for it although I really like mine. Oh and yeah, your work is always great, you'll get loads of fanboys sooner or later, like me. :D

[Mad Spike]

This is soo fkn childish. First they say you're the best, then they complain about the barcode being transparent. LAME! CRAP!
I just hate people who think they are soo damn good, who think the are pros, but when it comes to making something - they hide. They complain about the site being flooded by noobs, but THEY are the noobs who destroy the site. Cmon guys! Any of you, make a box that is better than mine! I DARE YOU! >:(((((
I would not be surprised if my box would fail against Arcanus. Now i know how people vote here. The look for every tiny little detail that doesn't even matter at all and say that it ruins everything, makes your box awful.
Unfortunatly, there is only one way. It's to be one of the best, and ignore cheating, unfair votes, etc.

[CruSadEr]

This is soo fkn childish. First they say you're the best, then they complain about the barcode being transparent. LAME! CRAP

Why are you targeting me? I voted for you! I am starting to think that votes can't just be based off perspective anymore.

[E_G]

Mad Spike, who are you accusing of cheating?

[Feed]

Why are you targeting me? I voted for you! I am starting to think that votes can't just be based off perspective anymore.

Ok, let me explain everything.

1 - Everytime someone submits a box there is someone who thinks its his duty to find some kind of flaw. It may be an oversized ESRB logo, missing dev logo, minor grammar mistake, wrond rating ( T instead of M ), doesn't matter. IMO, this is crap. These things do not ruin roxes, they don't make it worse.

And here were you, with your comment about the barcode being transparent. If you think this is a mistake that deserves to be mentioned, then fine, ill say everything about yours and anyones boxes. Ill tell how much they suck, how i hate seeing the same wallpeper used for 20th time, how bad people can use photshop, how poor their image manipulations are. I don't care who you vote for, these comments just make me nervous.

2 -


Mad Spike, who are you accusing of cheating?
I am not Mad Spike but ill explain this.
every forum and community has its own Veterans, people who have been visiting that forum for a quite long time. They talk with others, they gain popularity and respect. In our case you were that veteran. This means that your chances in winning any contest against someone, who is new to this forum are bigger. Much bigger. But this does not meant that you are the cheater.
Its people who vote for someone who they know better. The voting system is unfair.

Here's an exaple: Someone joined our community 2 days ago and asked for a competioiton. Some veteran agreed to compete. They both finished their boxes and submitted it. Then, when it comes to voting people vote for that veteran because they know him better and they cannot allow some newcomer to win.

To avoid these kind of thing i would like to suggest this: From now, any competitions should have new rules. When voting, people should explain why they vot against or for someone. And if the reason is pathetic and stupid ( small dev logo and stuff) - ignore that voice.


Sorry if you could not understand someting, my english is not perfect.

[CruSadEr]

Ok Feed. Your box was amazing. I absolutely loved it. I faved it too! Although, those descriptions are still corny:p

[Mad Spike]

Mad Spike, who are you accusing of cheating?
I am here for a long time also saw a lot of cheating, unfair voices, dishonest estimations and so on. The most terrible that it causes a rage and desire to revenge the same way. This destroys the comunity.
That is why my advise is to ignore it. And what to not feel yourself a looser it is necessary to be simple one of the best. Feed consults with the second item, but he cannot ignore.
Can be made voting without names. A box one and a box two. Nobody knows for whom it votes.

[E_G]

Feed I agree with what you said about veterans and biases. That is why I don't use a poll and have people state good reasons in the rounds I host, I was the one who challenged you after all so I should've reminded you to create the thread in this way.

I just hope that people don't think I've tried to influence the votes.