VGBA Summer Contest: Hunter Verses Timmeh

[E_G]

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/shadysaiyan/VgbaSummerCompBanner.jpg
Hunter
http://img124.imageshack.us/img124/5126/hl2tobcompboxbyhunterv2cm1.png
Timmeh
http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/4162/fearcopyfi5gc4.jpg

The person with the first six votes wins. You must have a good reason behind your vote.

Please vote for your favorite box by posting.
Hunter 0 Timmeh 6
Timmeh wins his round but Hunter loses with dignity.

[Themanslayer009]

i love them both but the orange box is just to orange im gonna have to go with Timmeh

[shadysaiyan]

hmmm, well to be honest i dont like how hunter put the poster edges effect on the characters and (i think ) the cutout efect on the robot. doesnt have the series look anymore. timmeh's is well, very good, even if it does look close to the official one, its very good.

I vote for Timmeh

[E_G]

i love them both but the orange box is just to orange
Lol, I think that's the point. Nonetheless, Hunter's box is good but I kinda agree with what Shadysaiyan said, and Timmeh's looks very professional.

I vote for Timmeh.

[Dark_Shadow]

both are really good but for an orange box it' a litlle too much orange :o
I vote for Timmeh

[Hunter]

Lol i knew that this is was going to happen , i couldn't do anything the robots were hard to cut out out of that orange wallpaper. so i decided to add everything on-top of it ~_~ , anyhow I'm gonna get a second chance in this contest so no heads well be chainsawed yet =P

[PunisherAB]

These boxes are good.:p

Hunter box is creative for a Half-life box and has very different art styles in it.

Timmeh box is very official and very nicely done....but it seems like I seen this before.:confused:

anyway, cause of some flaws of Hunter box and Timmeh box being more flawless...

Timmeh for the Win

[Lodovicok]

Both are rather good, yet Hunter's choice of effects really puts me off. Even though it seems his involved more effort, I am going to vote for Timmeh's because of it's cleansiness.

[Hunter]

hmmm, well to be honest i dont like how hunter put the poster edges effect on the characters and (i think ) the cutout efect on the robot. doesnt have the series look anymore.
i didn't cut out the robot if i did cut-it out i wouldn't made the box similar to orange juice :p , and the "the Orange Box" edition is kinda like collectors edition so i had to make it look special and not like any other normal boxes.

[CruSadEr]

I like Hunter's, but Timmeh's, like everyone else has said, has much more cleansliness. It look's very official, let's just hope he didn't steal it!:cool:

[Timmeh]

Its was a good match.

But I don't know what this is about me stealing the box, I would never steal a box art. You can even see the PSD if you want.