VGBA Summer Contest: Ayron verses IceFox

[E_G]

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/shadysaiyan/VgbaSummerCompBanner.jpg
Ayron
http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/2566/d3copy2lh9.jpg
IceFox
http://img101.imageshack.us/img101/3668/elebitsicefoxreleasetr9.png

The person with the first six votes wins. You must have a good reason behind your vote.

Please vote for your favorite box by posting.
Ayron 1 IceFox 6
IceFox wins his round but Ayron loses with dignity.

[E_G]

...and before anyone asks, I think Elebits surprising does classify itself in the first-person shooter genre. It's a light Gun Shooter / First Person Adventure which just about counts.

IceFox's nice and I love the colors, and I think Ayron's is stretched but not too bad.

So I vote for IceFox.

[PunisherAB]

I like them both and as EG said, Elebits does counts as a First-Person Adventure..which is in the same category as FPS.

Ayron box is great, has a great feel to the DooM series and love the effect...too bad their isn't a BG and it's a bit stretched.

Icefox box has a nice colorful view to the Elebit game and is looking great! He downside is that the bg is too wide and give the box more of a empty space.

Still, Icefox has fewer errors so I pick

IceFox for the Win!

[yoman44]

I vote Icefox

I would say like EG and Punisher so I be mute.

[Ayron]

lol, wasn't stretched before. xD
great job ice!

[Ninjamojo27]

I vote for IceFox's b/c his is clean and is presented well. Ayron's is good, but his logo lost it for me.

[werdney]

This is a really hard decision. I like both a lot, but Ayrons has a few little problems, and IceFoxes seems more organized. For example, Ayrons temp is off at the top a bit. So I vote IceFox

[Project Shadow]

Don't hate me, but I'm going with Ayron. Besides the bad quality, I like that it shows action happening in the game, whereas IceFox's is like a concept art (not saying you slapped a template on artwork). Great job, both of you!

[lord_arcanus]

i agree with everyone else, i vote for icefox.

you did well ayron, don't feel bad about it ;)

[Ayron]

lolz i don't.
icefox is the better one here =]
-edit- ofcourse i feel bad for losing.. but i did what i could do ;)

[Mad Spike]

Looks like my vote is the final one :)
Ayron's box problem - is unquality.
IceFox looks more qualitive, but: Concept art to the box is not a good idea (c)
My vote is for the IceFox

[E_G]

Thanks for all your votes. Good luck in the second chance rounds Ayron.

[Ayron]

Thanks alot EG!
i feel lucky to have at least one vote ;)
gratz ice, and i wish you good luck in the next round.

[IceFox]

Thanks alot EG!
i feel lucky to have at least one vote ;)
gratz ice, and i wish you good luck in the next round.
Just a suggestion (not that I am an expert or anything :p) would be to find a higher-res logo and make the person blend in with the BG a bit better. Your box was great, those were the only two main issues with it.

Still surprised I won. Thanks everyone :)

[Ayron]

ah i knew you would win dude =]
Thanks for the tips.
and it was really hard to find a hi-res logo o.o'

[IceFox]

ah i knew you would win dude =]
Thanks for the tips.
and it was really hard to find a hi-res logo o.o'
I can see that. I agree, finding one for Elebits was hard. I ended up just manually cutting out the one from the official cover and modifying it too make it sexier :p

Took me a while :p

Again though, your Doom 3 box is really good.

I am assuming the next task is assigned on the 9th?

[Hajimaru]

Ayron's box was cool! but i also vote for Icefox because his is colorfull i guess its more my taste or something both did a very good job :D

[Ratchetcomand]

Even thought i'm late i'm going to say Iced Fox because his box looks cool and i love the colors .