VGBA Summer Cotest: Werney verses Sockey

[E_G]

http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/shadysaiyan/VgbaSummerCompBanner.jpg
Werdney
http://img528.imageshack.us/img528/3047/reumbrellaxr6xp9.png
SockeyMeow
http://img514.imageshack.us/img514/7272/halflife2boxay7.png

The person with the first six votes wins. You must have a good reason behind your vote.

Please vote for your favorite by posting.
Werdney 1 SockeyMeow 6

SockeyMeow wins his round but Werdney loses with dignity.

[lord_arcanus]

you spelt Werdney's name wrong in the thread title. :p

I'm going to vote for sockeymeow's, because his looks cleaner, but the logo is too dark. werdney's is really good but those people on the left really ruin it.

SOCKEYMEOW

[DeathSpawn11]

Sockey's is clean and well done, I don't like how theres an inner glow on the logo but as Sockey told me he couldn't do anything about it. Werdneys is ok but the floating characters kill it, and the hands are badly overlayed in there. so my vote goes to

SockeyMeow

[E_G]

you spelt Werdney's name wrong in the thread title. :p
I've noticed I spelt that and contest incorrectly by accident, but let me off. The weather is scorching today:eek:. I hope Reed or a moderator can fix this for me.

Anyway, Werdney's box is not bad but SockeyMeow's looks a lot more real.
I vote for SockeyMeow.

[Ninjamojo27]

I vote for Sockey's b/c his is well presented and and looks official. Werdney's was ruined with the people on the left.

[werdney]

Oh, I thought this wasn't til the 9th. Oh well. Looks like I'll get beat, I'll even vote for Sockey, cause mine really sucks. I was debating whether or not to put the people in; when I put it on the front page I'll take them out. Sockeys is a lot more professional. I vote for him. lol.

[E_G]

Oh, I thought this wasn't til the 9th. Oh well. Looks like I'll get beat, I'll even vote for Sockey, cause mine really sucks. I was debating whether or not to put the people in; when I put it on the front page I'll take them out. Sockeys is a lot more professional. I vote for him. lol.
9th June is the deadline for when boxes should be finished. These threads get created every time a pair finishes their boxes. Apologies for if you think that I didn't make that clear enough.

EDIT: Also competitors can't vote in the thread that they're against someone in.

[Ratchetcomand]

I vote for Sockey because it looks officail and realy cool looking.

[Mad Spike]

As the professor of HL2 boxes should scarify box HL2 that on the Alyx's place there is a huge black spot. And a logo is dark, and there is too many of the empty space. Though, I recognize, that it looks well. I do not want, that my voice was solving, therefore I shall vote for Werdney. It seems to me, that in its box it is used much more art and different effects. It is not so qualitative, but idea not bad. So my vote for:
Werdney

[lord_arcanus]

don't forget Mad Spike, this is half-life 2 episode one, so i'm guessing it doesnt need to be as detailed as a normal HL2, but hey, it's all fair...

[shadysaiyan]

werdney's box doesnt look very presentable, and i feel like its random. sockey's is nice, looks official, but i think everything on the front should be brought down some. anyway

I vote for Sockey

[werdney]

Well, looks like I'm in the losers round. Not that I really expected to be anywhere else though.:rolleyes:
The chances of this are low, but could I maybe get the category for the next losers round? Or even a hint?

[lord_arcanus]

Don't worry Werdney, i'll probably be with you, Feed is going to pulverize me.

[E_G]

The chances of this are low, but could I maybe get the category for the next losers round? Or even a hint?
If you have any suggestions for what the next round could be, you might as well tell me in VG Box Art Summer Competition Round 1 thread.


Also thanks for all your votes.

[Mad Spike]

don't forget Mad Spike, this is half-life 2 episode one, so i'm guessing it doesnt need to be as detailed as a normal HL2, but hey, it's all fair...
It's second episode. And... well... Episode Two even less detailed then the EP1 or normal HL2 :D

[lord_arcanus]

oops, sorry about that

[finalfantaseer22]

even though its too late, i just want to say i really like the zombie hands on werdney's. and although sockey's looks good, its fairly simple and doesnt look like there was much effort

[sockeymeow]

yes there was i had to add a lot of photo filters and dims to it

[Feed]

sockeymeow.



Don't worry Werdney, i'll probably be with you, Feed is going to pulverize me.

WHERE IS YOUR GOD NOW!? :D