VGBA Competition: FFSeer22 vs. Codemaster

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/VGBASpringheader-1.png

Finalfantaseer22:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/seerbox.png

TheCodeMaster:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/codemasterbox.jpg

Finalfantaseer22:
/ / / / / / .

TheCodeMaster:
. . . . . . .

[Radioactive Bob]

SWEET GEORGIA BROWN!!!
They're both so good. But I have to go with FF22, his is a lot more clean and has a more sophisticated style to it.

[E_G]

I vote for Finalfantaseer22 too. On Finalfantaseer22's the composition and the recurrence of the colors are staggering, and whilst I prefer the style of the TheCodeMaster's and how he presented the screen shots, he used artwork from Final Fantasy Agito XIII on the front which is a big mistake in my book.

[shadysaiyan]

I vote for Finalfantaseer22 too. On Finalfantaseer22's the composition and the recurrence of the colors are staggering, and whilst I prefer the style of the TheCodeMaster's and how he presented the screen shots, he used artwork from Final Fantasy Agito XIII on the front which is a big mistake in my book.

I'm gonna have to go with FF22 on this one, the excellence of it all is scary, but so greatly executed., codemaster's is good, but the front takes away from that, the back is very nice. also i dont like that template.....soo...

I vote for FinalFantaseer22

[PunisherAB]

Finalfantaseer22 will get my vote. It's has a great feeling to it and looks great as well.:D I think this is his best. Code is great as well, but I like Finalfantaseer22 better.

[Hunter]

both of them have flaws.
FF22
1- square enix logo is huge
Codemaster
1- the square enix logo is huge
2- you can see in the copyright says (PS2) so yeah ...
3- i don't like how he placed that quote on the top back of the box , it makes it look cheap
4- i don't like how the background on the front is red

my vote goes to FFseer22

[thecodemaster]

I guess you could say, well, I'm getting... battered.

[lord_arcanus]

the codemaster's looks cool but all PAL final fantasy boxes are plain white (with a tiny bit of extra things in the background) but the back is cool. i vote for FF22 because his looks more realistic, but they both look cool.

[thecodemaster]

I considered just having the official logo on a white background, but it looked too boring :p

Ah well, there's always the NEXT competition.