VGBA Competiton: E.G. vs. Hunter

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/VGBASpringheader-1.png

Hunter wins! Congratulations to both competitors on a job well done. Hunter will move on to the next round, and Electric General will continue on to battle for the title of Subchampion.

Electric General:

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/EGbox.png

Hunter:

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/Hunterbox.png

Electric General:
/ / / / / . .

Hunter:
/ / / / / / /

[lord_arcanus]

I just KNEW i would see Final Fantasy boxes here !!

they are both incredible . It's too difficult to vote , i cannot decide . They both look so proffessional .

[Ratchetcomand]

I like Hunter box because his looks more officail then E.G .

[KoopaDasher]

I personally go for Hunter's as well. EG's looks more like a modern Final Fantasy box, but Hunter's looks more like one from that generation of systems would have looked.

[lord_arcanus]

i hate to go off-topic, but on the FF8 box, the guy is Leon, right? (i was wondering because on KH2 it says Leon is from FF8)

[Ratchetcomand]

i hate to go off-topic, but on the FF8 box, the guy is Leon, right? (i was wondering because on KH2 it says Leon is from FF8)

Yes it him but in Final Fantasy 8 his name is Squall Leonhart .

[Sonic7]

I vote for hunter

[KILLERMIKE]

e.g because of higher def.and official looking

[Ninjamojo27]

I vote for Hunter b/c his has more detail put into it than E.G's

[shadysaiyan]

I like them both though i never played FF8. EG's looks good, but im gonna have to go with hunters. Koopa pretty much said what i was going to say.

I vote Hunter

also, i was going to do Final Fantasy 7, but now.....well i probably wont.

[E_G]

EG's looks more like a modern Final Fantasy box, but Hunter's looks more like one from that generation of systems would have looked.
I disagree, Final Fantasy boxes on the PSone were done in the same style as they are now. In my opinion Hunter's doesn't look that official, I mean he used the wrong rating logo, I used the correct outdated one, he used the wrong template, the outline of his only would go with the European ones like here (http://i11.ebayimg.com/01/i/000/96/c0/9d94_1.JPG), my template was based on the official US one. I'm not just saying this in an attempt to try to influence the votes but just to make sure I don't get cast aside because people aren't getting some of their facts straight which wouldn't be fair on me.

[KoopaDasher]

I disagree, Final Fantasy boxes on the PSone were done in the same style as they are now. In my opinion Hunter's doesn't look that official, I mean he used the wrong rating logo, I used the correct outdated one, he used the wrong template, the outline of his only would go with the European ones like here (http://i11.ebayimg.com/01/i/000/96/c0/9d94_1.JPG), my template was based on the official US one. I'm not just saying this in an attempt to try to influence the votes but just to make sure I don't get cast aside because people aren't getting some of their facts straight which wouldn't be fair on me.

Well, I still think his..well, I just like it. Don't get me wrong, yours is amazing. I had to pick my jaw up off of the floor when I saw it, but for the purposes of this round, this generation, his just looks more like an old game, whereas yours would make a great re-do of the game on a modern system.

[Radioactive Bob]

My vote goes to General. His, in my opinion, really does look more professional. He used the proper rating, template, and everything. Hunter's may look older, but General's looks more official.

[E_G]

Well, I still think his..well, I just like it.
Whatever you say, in future I'll just disregard a lot of realism and use a filter on an official wallpaper (http://c-uncut.com/wp/ff7wp-12.jpg) to woo people.

[Tales of Symphony]

i vote eg. his is a more attractive box, that actually used the old format. he put the effort in, and the fact that it is just a wallpaper leads me to believe that his is the better box

electric general

[ffseer22incontestform]

Whatever you say, in future I'll just disregard a lot of realism and use a filter on an official wallpaper (http://c-uncut.com/wp/ff7wp-12.jpg) to woo people.

i agree, i was wondering if that even counted as "editing" an image...

[KoopaDasher]

i agree, i was wondering if that even counted as "editing" an image...

You have a point. I'm changing my vote. Sorry EG. As I said, your box is great.

[KILLERMIKE]

hunter his seems more official

[KoopaDasher]

hunter his seems more official

Does that mean you vote for him?

[KILLERMIKE]

yep it does

[lord_arcanus]

I vote for the General because as he and some others said he used proper materials. They are both stunning, but I say General because it's more official-looking.

And I understand that Hunter's looks more old, but actually most PS1 boxes didn't look like that. They looked just like PS2 boxes nowadays.

[thecodemaster]

My vote goes to Hunter. Sorry E.G.

[E_G]

My vote goes to Hunter. Sorry E.G.
Lack of reasoning for the lose.

[Tales of Symphony]

I dont understand why you are still voting for hunters, when all he did was put a wallpaper on a template and add the logo and that stuff.

[E_G]

They must also have a good reason.


So that means you're not going to accept Sonic7's and thecodemaster's votes unless they give good reasons behind their votes, am I right? Well the poll doesn't look that way. :o

[Hunter]

c'mon guys give reasons so i can win :p

[KoopaDasher]

So that means you're not going to accept Sonic7's and thecodemaster's votes unless they give good reasons behind their votes, am I right? Well the poll doesn't look that way. :o


He has a point....you need to include reasoning behind your vote. It's only respectful to the artist. :o

[Hunter]

I vot for hunter... will someone just respond??? http://www.vgboxart.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1960&replies=8
give them a reason , plz and i will respond

[Mist]

My vote goes to Hunter because it just looks more appealing. Even though it may just be a wallpaper with a logo on it, it gets more of my attention than EG's box, which looks a little empty, IMO.

[Black_Knight]

Sorry EG, but Hunter's just looks for professional, in my opinion. Your's is good, but his just looks more polished. I vote Hunter.

[Hunter]

yay i win :) . thanks for all the votes guys

[HellKnight]

I have to go for E.G his box just look nice and simple yet brilliant at the same time, the coulors and the over all look just appeal to me more.

[Ninjamojo27]

I have to go for E.G his box just look nice and simple yet brilliant at the same time, the coulors and the over all look just appeal to me more.
A lil late there buddy.

[Hunter]

Hunter wins! Congratulations to both competitors on a job well done. Hunter will move on to the next round, and Electric General will continue on to battle for the title of Subchampion.

and i thought i would never hear you saying that :p, great match EG and good luck on the next one

[HellKnight]

A lil late there buddy.

yeh i actualy posted that like an hour ago :confused: i have no idea why it has only just come up.

[E_G]

Well it was close so you shoudn't be so sarcastic about that Hunter. I'm sorry I was harsh on your box but I didn't think everyone was being fair, like using the word creativity in such an incorrect context, and I had to bring my reasoning into it. I liked your box actually, it was nothing personal.

[Hunter]

Well it was close so you shoudn't be so sarcastic about that Hunter. I'm sorry I was harsh on your box but I didn't think everyone was being fair, like using the word creativity in such an incorrect context, and I had to bring my reasoning into it. I liked your box actually, it was nothing personal.
don't apologize man , you weren't harsh at all . i agree that my box art is isn't that great cause i only used a wallpaper . which isn't very creative

[PunisherAB]

Damn it! I miss to vote. :(
But if I could still vote, I would for for EG. His is more hi-def and has a nice design for a final fantasy Box, while Hunter is small and has a cool design too, but I though the layout of EG's box is much better.

Congrads to both boxes. :)

[E_G]

Damn, you fail me my servants.