VGBA Competition: PunisherAB vs. Ninjamojo

[KoopaDasher]

http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/VGBASpringheader-1.png

Punisher wins! Congratulations to both competitors! Punisher will advance to the next round, and Ninjamojo will join the ranks of those competing for the title of sub champion!

Punisher:
http://i176.photobucket.com/albums/w166/KoopaDasher/punisherbox.png


Ninjamojo:
http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w37/BoxArtist/MetalGear-1.jpg

PunisherAB:
/ / / / / / /

Ninjamojo:
/ / / / / . .

[PunisherAB]

I just want to point out that I drew that sonic render. I drew it and edited it in illustrator and Photoshop. I also make the logo custom too. :D

Enjoy! :D

[Ninjamojo27]

Me, I had to cut out all thos people from one blended pic. ANd also, I forgot to save as PNG. JPG killed it. I am a dumbass...

[TwilightMystics]

My vote goes to Punisher, because first it is kinda the cartoony version of the official Sonic Xtreme box ( that never came out ), second everything is so creative( a bit simplistic) but nice.:o

Anyways Ninjamojo's looks like it's not done, there is a white bar on the right side, To make it good, Ninja should have put more effort innit;)

[Ninjamojo27]

I didnt even see that white stripe. It was a black stripe so I erased it.

[Dark_Shadow]

i choose punisher cuz I like the cartoony look of it :D

btw ninjamojo yours is pretty cool too just like you did'nt have enough time cuz its the beginning of a box... there's missing something :confused:

[E_G]

PunisherAB's has great energy to it and is fantastic resolution. He definitely gets my vote.
PS: I didn't know you were such a good drawer. :D

[KILLERMIKE]

my vote is on ninja

[PunisherAB]

PunisherAB's has great energy to it and is fantastic resolution. He definitely gets my vote.
PS: I didn't know you were such a good drawer. :D

I didn't know I was either. :D Those Art classes payed off. :P

[PunisherAB]

my vote is on ninja

Well, your vote doesn't count untill you have a reason.

[lord_arcanus]

my vote is on ninja

you need to explain yourself.

[Ninjamojo27]

you need to explain yourself.
WEll, who do you vote for?

[KILLERMIKE]

sorry,yes my vote is on him because of the simple feel to it.and plus i love metal gear solid games.

[lord_arcanus]

I vote for Punisher. Sorry Ninja, yours is mind-blowing, and it perfectly captures the feel to the MGS series, but the sonic one is so clean and hi-res, and it looks so realistic. sorry man, but i'm gonna vote for AB.

[KoopaDasher]

I vote for Ninja too. Sorry Punisher, but the XTREME part of the logo is really choppy and ruins it for me. Ninja's may be smaller, but I think it looks more official. I just can't see a drawing like that being used for a Sonic box. I may be wrong, but that's my vote.

[DeathSpawn11]

well my vote goes to Punisher, his is very well put together while Ninja's feels like it's not done.

PS: Punisher you're lucky I managed to get myself on the internet...

[Radioactive Bob]

I can't decide, so I just wanted to stop by and say good job to both of them. :p

[Ratchetcomand]

I like Ninja because his box looks more officail then punishers .

[PunisherAB]

I vote for Ninja too. Sorry Punisher, but the XTREME part of the logo is really choppy and ruins it for me. Ninja's may be smaller, but I think it looks more official. I just can't see a drawing like that being used for a Sonic box. I may be wrong, but that's my vote.

Man, you wern't kidding when you said that the N64 was your first system. :D

But a vote is a vote....I wonder who will win.:rolleyes:

[Ninjamojo27]

Man, you wern't kidding when you said that the N64 was your first system. :D

But a vote is a vote....I wonder who will win.:rolleyes:
Dont get to cocky...I GOT 3 VOTES MISTER!

[PunisherAB]

Dont get to cocky...I GOT 3 VOTES MISTER!

lol don't get mad....did I say I was wining? No:D

Don't get mad, get Glad™. :cool:

[sockeymeow]

I'm gonna vote for Punisher sorry Ninja but his has a little more pizazz

[Ninjamojo27]

lol don't get mad....did I say I was wining? No:D

Don't get mad, get Glad™. :cool:
I was joking.

[PunisherAB]

I was joking.

I know...so was I. :eek:

:D

[Ninjamojo27]

I know...so was I. :eek:

:D
Soo we coo, right? Your still gonna beat me though.

[shadysaiyan]

Well they are both pretty good. On punishers box:
Pros: Has a classic sonic look to it. the cartoon version of sonic looks nice. Cons: the logo isnt very good and the "Xtreme" part is pretty choppy, the drawing is nice, but it takes attention away from the background and seeing the background, dont even know whats supposed to be back there.

Ninja's
Pros:Looks just like a metal gear solid box would look like, renders are cut nicely.
Cons: Does look rushed somewhat, since there is no background. but you did have until sunday.

My Vote goes to Ninja

[finalfantaseer22]

i mostly agree with everyone, however in this case i like ninjamojo's better, i can picture his more on teh shelves, AB's sonic box looks more liek a printmaster school poster project or something, the template slightly blurry and the "xtreme" is choppy, and teh background isn't very attractive. ninja's is simple with the b and w fits well with the style, and there's not many faults.
my vote goes to Ninjamojo

[Sergant Johnson]

I'm goina have to vote for Punisher. His is just more retro and appealing. I also like that he drew Sonic. Great work Buell.

[Ninjamojo27]

GG AB. I almost caught up.

[PunisherAB]

GG AB. I almost caught up.

Yes, you almost did. Nice job with your box. You did a good job with it. It's simplistic and MGS stylish. :D

[Ninjamojo27]

Yes, you almost did. Nice job with your box. You did a good job with it. It's simplistic and MGS stylish. :D
Yours was greatly drawn. Where did you learn to do that?

[PunisherAB]

Yours was greatly drawn. Where did you learn to do that?

Lots of pratice with cartoons and a art class and Graphic Design Class in college.